Intel, Almunia and 1 billion euros for unfair potatoes

Intel Logo

“The General Court upholds the fine of 1.06 billion euros ($ 1.4 billions) imposed on Intel for having abused its dominant position on the market for x86 central processing units between 2002 and 2007”. With these words the judge of the General Court of the European Union dismissed Intel’s action against the decision of the Commission in its entirety last week. The record fine closed a long antitrust question between the US microchip giant and the European Commission.

Let’s see now how the American giant played an unfair game in the European market. With a decision taken on 13 May 2009 the Commission imposed a fine of €1.06 billion on Intel, the American microchip manufacturer, for having abused its dominant position on the market for x86 CPUs, in infringement of the competition rules of the EU and the European Economic Area (EEA), the court explained in a press release.

Europe fined Intel, which had a market share of around 70 percent in 2009, for impeding AMD’s ability to compete between October 2002 and October 2007. The European Commission argued that Intel acted in an ‘unfair’ way “by implementing a strategy aimed at foreclosing from the market its only serious competitor, Advanced Micro Devices, Inc.”. Intel was basically awarding rebates to computer makers like Dell and HP, if they bought exclusively or mostly Intel-made CPUs, the most important bit of the computer you are reading this article through. The Commission considered that Intel was in a dominant position and that it was extremely difficult for competitors to enter the market and to expand.

Allegedly Intel also made payments to computer makers (HP, Acer and Lenovo), if they agreed to postpone or cancel the launch of computers that contained CPUs made by AMD, and/or putting restrictions on the distribution of those products, EU officials claimed. Intel has argued that it was not working outside the frames of the law and said to Reuters that “it’s a complex case” that cannot be broken down that easily. Intel, through the voice of its spokeswoman Sophie Jacobs, declared that there’s big “disappointment with the decision”. “None of the arguments raised by Intel supports the conclusion that the fine imposed is disproportionate,” the Court replied, given also that DG Competition fines for anti-trust violations can reach a maximum of 10 percent of a company’s annual turnover, if that is found ‘guilty’. For Intel, the penalty was equivalent to 4.8 percent of the company’s 2008 turnover. So they should be happy already.

The Commission openly welcomed the outcome last week and so did BEUC, the European Consumer Organisation (BEUC stands for French “Bureau Européen des Unions de Consommateurs”). Monique Goyens, BEUC’s Director General commented: “When large companies abuse their dominance of the market, it causes direct harm to consumers. The Court’s ruling issued a strong reminder that such behaviour is illegal and unacceptable. Antitrust actions can help clean the market and this record fine should serve as an expensive deterrent against companies abusing oversized market shares”, BEUC reported.

Intel’s fine remains the largest ever for breaching Europe’s competition laws. The European Commission has been thoroughly monitoring the technology industry. It has already launched antitrust cases against Google and Microsoft, and continues to say that it will “police the technology industry where necessary”. Silicon Valley is trembling not without a reason.

There are always two ways to look at it though. This might be seen as a fight between the ‘free market’ in which a company does everything possible to gain market share and a watchdog which tries to keep the market controlled. However, what should be well considered is that Intel was not found ‘innocent’ for a good reason; the Californian company actually tried to control the market itself, not being the ‘free market’ champion, again, but  the one that wanted to control the market in a ‘monopolistic’ manner. Some say that DG Competition has not accurately considered the economic effects of Intel’s decision through the years, but the truth is that when there is evidence of a long term ‘unfair’ strategy, a market is no longer free and authorities are called to draw the line. This is not Europe’s innovative breakthrough but every free market’s role in the world.

The question many are asking is whether 1 billion euros is too much a fine. Or too low maybe? BEUC’s Monique Goyens last week probably introduced the most important aspect for this kind of questions: “Consumers harmed by Intel’s long-lasting misconduct were left out of any compensation”. Are consumers truly free when several years later an antitrust case is proved to have been influencing the market and its terms?

It’s easy to forget that the most important thing in a market which can call itself “free” is not only the freedom of an entrepreneurial mind to make ambitious business plans without asking his mom but also equally important is the freedom of choice of the consumer of the market. Europe has long been a champion in protecting its consumers by setting high standards and instead of everyone attacking Almunia and his team maybe they need to be more transparent and fair in their price strategies and business development plans.

Everyone if free to conquer the world market with chips or potatoes against competitors but only in a way that does not kill the market. Good competition ethics by giants like Intel, Microsoft and Google is a must in Europe. Only like that products can be of the highest standards, the price as low as possible and only then the consumer will be able to do the impossible, make a rational purchase decision. At least she will try.

Advertising

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Execution of juvenile offender in Iran ‘deeply distressing’ – UN rights chief

Crucial medical supplies airlifted to north-east Syria to meet ‘desperate need’

Who and why want the EU-US trade agreement here and now

‘Compelling case’ for urgency around global disarmament, UN-led forum told

E-cigars: Improbable ally or enemy in disguise?

“A Junior Enterprise is run only by students.. there are no professors or managers that can help you solve your problems”

Intervene, don’t overthink – the new mantra of systems design

TTIP’s 11th round major takeaways and the usual “leaked” document

Opposite cultures: Should it be a problem?

Pledging ongoing UN support during visit to cyclone-hit areas, Guterres praises resilience of Mozambicans

Air quality: Commission takes action to protect citizens from air pollution

Sustainable development demands a broader vision, says new OECD Development Centre report

How oysters are cleaning New York’s polluted harbor

EU seeks foreign support on 5G from Mobile World Congress 2015 as the “digital gold rush” begins

SMEs and micro firms sinking together with south Eurozone

“The markets have moved on renewables, policy makers must keep up”, A Sting Exclusive by Erik Solheim, Head of UN Environment

UN Human Rights Council stands firm on LGBTI violence, Syria detainees and Philippines ‘war on drugs’

UK’s PM Theresa May asks for a two-year Brexit transition plan as negotiations round kicks off

Drought in Europe: Member States agree on support measures proposed by the Commission

Thursday’s Daily Brief: Climate crisis and food risks, fresh violence threat for millions of Syrians, calls for calm in Kashmir

Trade in counterfeit goods costs UK economy billions of euros

Refugee crisis update: EU still lacks solidarity as Hungary and Slovakia refuse to accept EU Court’s decision

How to future-proof India’s economy

EU’s judicial cooperation arm, Eurojust, to become more effective with new rules

Our healthcare systems are ailing. Here’s how to make them better

How universities can become a platform for social change

UNICEF backpacks used as a haunting symbol to call for greater protection of children living in conflict

Radioactive nuclear waste is a global threat. These scientists may have a new solution

OECD leading multilateral efforts to address tax challenges from digitalisation of the economy

Iraq protests: UN calls for national talks to break ‘vicious cycle’ of violence

A Europe that protects: EU reports on progress in fighting disinformation ahead of European Council

Commission presents EU-Vietnam trade and investment agreements for signature and conclusion

Blue bonds: What they are, and how they can help the oceans

Obesity rates soar due to dramatic global diet shift, says UN food agency

Coronavirus crisis: “Commission will use all the tools at its disposal to make sure the European economy weathers the storm”

Mexico must increase foreign bribery enforcement: full implementation of anti-corruption reforms could help

Two peacekeepers killed in an attack against UN convoy in Mali

EuroLat plenary in Panama: control of trade talks and fight against crime

Is the English language too powerful?

Trade: First year of the EU-Japan Economic Partnership Agreement shows growth in EU exports

UN agriculture agency digs in to help forests and farms build resilience to climate change

Disaster Medicine in Medical Education: the investment you just can´t afford to ignore

A Sting Exclusive: “Infrastructure can lay the groundwork for the Sustainable Development Goals” by Mr Fulai Sheng, UN Environment Senior Economist

Commission proposes a governance framework for the Budgetary Instrument for Convergence and Competitiveness

Why enterprise risk management is the future for banks

Streaming music isn’t as green as you might think. Here’s why

‘Young people care about peace’: UN Youth Envoy delivers key message to Security Council

Why the ECB prepares to flood the markets with more and free of charge euro; everybody needs that now

Deal on tightening the rules to stop terrorists from using homemade explosives

A Europe that protects: Continued efforts needed on security priorities

International community renews commitment to multilateral efforts to address tax challenges from digitalisation of the economy

EU invests more than €100 million in new LIFE Programme projects to promote a green and climate-neutral Europe

What the car industry has done to help fight climate change – and what it needs to do next

MWC 2016 LIVE: Freemium MVNO model a success, claims FreedomPop head

This company is breeding millions of insects in the heart of London

Millions more migrant workers, means countries lose ‘most productive part’ of workforce

‘Brutal weather’ continues as Rohingya refugee children endure devastating rainfall in Bangladesh

Turkey remains numb while its economy is expected to shrink further due to a cocktail of EU and US sanctions

More taxpayers’ money for the banks

Electronic cigarettes – The alternative we’ve been looking for?

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s