Advocate General ‘outlaws’ Data Retention Directive

Press conference by Cecilia Malmström, Member of the European Commission in charge of Home Affairs, on the evaluation of the Data Retention Directive. She probably uses both hands to show us where the data for our communications are stored and await 'exploitation'. (EC Audiovisual Services).

Press conference by Cecilia Malmström, Member of the European Commission in charge of Home Affairs, on the evaluation of the Data Retention Directive. She probably uses both hands to show us where the data for our communications are stored and await ‘exploitation’. (EC Audiovisual Services).

The shallowness that the European Commission shows, while asked to protect the basic civil rights of EU citizens and companies, was ostentatiously proven in the case of the Data Retention Directive. According to the Advocate General of the Court of Justice of the European Union, Cruz Villalón, the Directive doesn’t provide the basic guarantees that the data stored for two years by the telephone or electronic communications providers won’t be used for other purposes than the ones stated in the Directive. The opinion of the Advocate General was published this morning. Of course the opinion of the Advocate General does not bind the judges of the Court. However, the legal soundness of the opinion is considered to be of extreme quality.

In must be noted that the Directive relates only to the traffic and the location of data for telephone and other electronic communications of all EU citizens and companies, and not to their content. Still, according to the Advocate general, “the use of those data may make it possible to create a both faithful and exhaustive map of a large portion of a person’s conduct strictly forming part of his private life, or even a complete and accurate picture of his private identity”. The logical conclusion of this observation is that when it comes to the business universe, the ‘map’ of an economic entity’s communications, if in the wrong hands, can be used even for industrial espionage purposes. Let alone that it leaves all citizens completely unprotected from unduly use of their communications mapping.

Open to industrial espionage

What Villalón briefly says is that the Directive doesn’t make sure that the communication providers take special care to protect the data neither are they obliged to store the data within the borders of the country in question. In reality, the data will be lying somewhere in the world, stored for two years available to any able intruder. Even the provider itself can make large profits, also somewhere in the world, out of selling the access to such data, even in a case by case basis. In this way the storing of the data may create another business ‘department’ for the provider.

The Commission’s directive doesn’t pay any attention whatsoever to all those factors. It truth, it facilitates the ‘commercial’ exploitation of the data. The opinion of the Advocate actually observes, that “There is, moreover, an increased risk that the retained data might be used for unlawful purposes which are potentially detrimental to privacy or, more broadly, fraudulent or even malicious”. This said, the opinion notes also that “the Directive – which indeed regulates neither access to the data collected and retained nor their use – assigns the task of defining and establishing those guarantees to the Member States. Accordingly, the Directive does not comply with the requirement, laid down by the Charter of Fundamental Rights”.

No guarantees provided

Consequently, “when the European Union legislature adopts, as in the case of the Data Retention Directive, an act imposing obligations which constitute serious interference with the fundamental rights of citizens of the Union, it must assume its share of responsibility by defining at the very least the principles which must govern the definition, establishment, application and review of observance of the necessary guarantees”.

Last but not least, the opinion says that two years of retention time for the data is disproportionate. No interested party has submitted to the court evidence supporting a time detention period larger than one year. The Judges of the Court are now beginning their deliberations in this case. Judgment will be given at a later date.

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

the European Sting Milestones

Featured Stings

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Can the EU really make Google and Facebook pay publishers and media?

How India is harnessing technology to lead the Fourth Industrial Revolution

Europe provides financial support to African countries while Turkey denies to change terrorism laws jeopardising the EU deal

The Irish Presidency bullies the Parliament over EU budget

Why do medical students need to emigrate to become doctors in 2017?

Why do medical students need to go abroad to become a doctor in 2017?

Hatred ‘a threat to everyone’, urges Guterres calling for global effort to end xenophobia and ‘loathsome rhetoric’

Does research make sense any more? The dire need for new ways to measure success

A Young student assesses the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA)

ECB intervenes to clean May’s and Schäuble’s mess

Around 52 million in Near East, North Africa, suffering chronic undernourishment, new UN food agency report reveals

Fed, ECB take positions to face the next global financial crisis; the Brits uncovered

These 4 Nordic countries hold the secret to gender equality

Why do medical students need to emigrate to become doctors in 2017?

Extra mild ECB tapering of QE and zero interest rates keep euro low

This incredibly detailed map of Africa could help aid and development

Hundreds of wounded Gaza protesters risk limb amputation without immediate help, warns top UN official

Ukraine undecided over a strategic partnership with the EU

6th Edition of India m2m + iot Forum 2019 concluded, in association with The European Sting

Impact of high debt levels on least developed countries ‘cannot be overstated’, says UN

UN agriculture chief urges ‘transformative changes’ to how we eat

‘Starvation’ now a reality for displaced Syrians stranded in camp near Jordanian border

No agreement in sight on EU budget

ILO and EIB join forces for more and better quality employment

Financial abuse of elderly ‘rampant, but invisible’, says UN expert

Libya: Attack on foreign ministry, an attack on all Libyans, stresses UN envoy

Why Microsoft is a regular to Almunia’s

Doctors are humans too: the benefits of embracing your mental status

EU Emissions Trading System does not hurt firms’ profitability

Human Rights Council election: 5 things you need to know about it

Electric vehicles are half the market in Norway

Brexit negotiations: back to square one, tougher words, no good faith

Commission deepens criticism on German economic policies

‘Bring to life’ precious moments caught on film or tape, UN agency urges on World Day

UN refugee agency ‘deeply shocked’ at stabbing death of ‘deeply courageous’ Polish mayor

Security Council unanimously agrees to extend UN Cyprus Mission amid political impasse

Ukraine: The West and Russia negotiate shares of influence

The West unites against Mali desert rebels

Reality Shock

Cybersecurity Act: build trust in digital technologies

Sahel crisis reaching unprecedented levels, warn top UN humanitarian officials

Confidence-building measures continue in new Yemen prisoner-swap talks

Advancing multilateralism goes ‘hand-in-hand’ with work of the UN

3+1 issues to haunt tomorrow’s EU Summit

How migrants who send money home have become a global economic force

‘Grave consequences’ await if new deadly escalation of violence in Gaza continues – top UN official

This is why mountains matter more than you think

MEPs take stock of the EU’s foreign, security and defence policy priorities

Eurostat confirms a dangerously fast falling inflation in Eurozone

An EU Summit without purpose

Parliament criticises Council’s rejection of money laundering blacklist

The succesful cooperation

Five ways to increase trust in e-commerce

A day in the life of a Venezuelan migrant in Boa Vista, Brazil

EU Council: The US airlines may freely pollute the European air

Summer JADE Meeting 2015: We came curious, we left inspired

The issue of health literacy and how it affects European health policies

One good reason to feel less blue about the future of our oceans

4 myths about manufacturing in the Fourth Industrial Revolution

Quality Education on the table at the European Parliament

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s