Germany may prove right rejecting Commission’s bank resolution scheme

ECON Committee meeting discussion with Commissioner Michel Barnier in charge of Internal Market and Services (on the right) on bank reform. In the Chair, Arlene McCarthy (S&D, UK) (in the middle), (European Parliament Audiovisual Services, 16/09/2013).

ECON Committee meeting discussion with Commissioner Michel Barnier in charge of Internal Market and Services (on the right) on bank reform. In the Chair, Arlene McCarthy (S&D, UK) (in the middle), (European Parliament Audiovisual Services, 16/09/2013).

Commissioner Michel Barnier, responsible for financial services, had a rough time yesterday at the Economic and Monetary Affairs Committee (ECON) of the European Parliament, when he told the legislators that the Commission will press ahead with its proposal about the creation under its own roof of the Single Resolution Mechanism (SRM) for Eurozone’s failing banks. He stressed that this can be done without a change in the Treaty of the European Union and added that the EU can insert a relevant amendment in the text of the new Treaty, whenever there will be one. Germany has already expressed its strong disapproval for the creation of an SRM as the Commission wants it without a change in the Treaty.

The questions the MEPs asked Barnier obviously doubted the legality and the soundness of the Commission’s proposal. They also questioned the viability of the source of funds to be used in eventual resolutions of Eurozone banks. The Committee will have an initial detailed discussion of the Commission’s proposed legislation this morning. The negative climate that prevailed yesterday in the ECON Committee doesn’t leave much hope that the Commission’s proposal will have an easy time either. Tough questions come from across the political spectrum.

Second blow

This is a second blow this proposal takes in a matter of a few days. Last Friday during the first meeting of the ECOFIN council, after the summer vacations that took place in the Lithuanian capital Vilnius, there was only a vague reference to this burning issue. There were no reports at all whether the SRM was discussed in the Eurogroup council, which is made up by the 17 ministers of Finance of the euro area countries and presumably it’s them who care most about the issue. Not even Michel Barnier, who was present in Vilnius said anything in public about it. The conclusion was that nobody wanted to discuss openly this issue during last weekend in the Lithuanian capital.

Coming back to ECON Committee’s session, Barnier faced yesterday key questions by legislators about this Commission’s proposal on the SRM. Before presenting that it must be noted that the creation of the SRM divides deeply the Eurozone countries, as well as the 28 EU members. Not to forget that this mechanism is the most important part of the Banking Union, that everybody agrees on the urgent need for its creation.

Commission’s SRM

As it is now clear, the Commission has finally decided to propose a Single Resolution Mechanism propelled by a Single Resolution Authority to be enacted under its own roof in Brussels. According to the executive arm of the EU, this SRA should have access to funding because it is highly possible that the resolution of a failing bank will leave behind liabilities which have to be covered. In view of this need of funds the Commission adds that a resolution fund should also be created, which will be capitalized by a small levy imposed regularly on all banks. If a resolution occurs before enough capital is accumulated in this fund the authority should be able to borrow from the European Stability Mechanism and pay the money back when the fund has stored enough wealth.

However all these proposals are a bit far-fetched. It’s very uncertain how this resolution levy will be imposed on all Eurozone banks. Would all of them be obliged to pay the same levy? If not, how will it be customized? The prudent and the careless bankers will pay the same levy? Will it be a tax? If not a tax then what?

In short, it is quite uncertain when or even if at all this levy is to be imposed. Only last week the Commission’s own legal service advised that the imposition of a special financial tax (The European financial transaction tax – FTT) in twelve willing to do so EU countries (Tobin Tax), is illegal. On top of that the European Court of Justice ruled that the power given to the EU markets watchdog, the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), to ban certain types of short selling, was illegal. All that mean that the legality and the fairness of a levy on all Eurozone banks to finance the resolution of the ones that go bust, is utterly uncertain. Consequently, if the resolution task is realised by the European Commission, the liabilities to be left behind a failing lender will create new obligations, which will be eventually covered by the ESM. In this way the burden to resolve for example an imprudent Greek or Spanish bank will be diffused to all Eurozone member states according to their participation in the ESM.

Mutualising the risks

Germany is the largest contributor to ESM and will thus pay also the largest part of the liabilities that the resolution of this possibly Greek or Spanish careless lender will leave uncovered. This is not at all fair, because everybody knows that a lot of banks in member states are up to their heads in not always clean dealings with their governments and local businesses. The less clean those dealings, the more prone the banks are to go bust and burden the German taxpayer. This is exactly what Germany wants to avoid and demands for a change in the Treaty. The reasoning behind is that such a mutualisation of financial risks has to have very strong political and legal foundations, because it will mutualise financial responsibilities that nobody can estimate their magnitude. It is an open secret that the banks hide in their books immeasurable risks not always quite clean.

No wonder why MEPs from across the political spectrum pressed the Commissioner yesterday for more details about the enactment and the workings of the bank resolution regime. “Would the Commission push ahead with its plans despite Germany’s resistance? asked Peter Simon (S&D, DE). Could the planned EU resolution fund borrow money from the European Stability Mechanism (ESM) until it was fully capitalised by banks’ contributions? asked Wolf Klinz (ALDE, DE)”. Mr Barnier answered he did not see any problem with the new fund borrowing from the ESM or from other sources. Responding to Mr Simon, he said he was open to amending the treaties but did not see this as a pre-requisite.

All the answers Barnier gave are quite open to criticism. If the resolution authority starts borrowing from the ESM to deal with failing banks, as the Commissioner proposed, the Mechanism may soon end up dry and unable to perform the task it was created for that is to support the Eurozone member states in need. Then Barnier almost carelessly added that the resolution authority may borrow “from other sources”, as if the streets of Brussels were full of other financial sources. Last but not least, his answer to Peter Simon going approximately like this, “let’s first create the resolution authority and then legalise it with a change in the Treaty”, must have made Barnier look sloppy and superficial. No surprise if this Commission proposal would be met with strong reservations today when the MEPs will discuss it in-depth.

There is no doubt that this Commission proposal may end up in the dustbin and the German proposal for the ‘nationalisation and decentralisation of bank resolutions’ goes ahead.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Challenges facing the COVID-19 vaccination campaigns

Civilian deaths in Afghanistan hit record high – UN

Visiting North Korea, UN relief chief spotlights funding shortfall to meet humanitarian needs

Meet Alice, the battery-powered plane that could herald the age of electric air travel

Britain in and out of the EU

Statement by the Brexit Steering Group on UK government White paper

Cocaine and opium production worldwide hit ‘absolute record highs’ – major threat to public health says UN study

Ebola: EU releases additional €3.5 million to tackle epidemic

Voices of young climate action activists ‘give me hope’ says UN chief

European Semester 2019 Spring Package: Commission issues recommendations for Member States to advance sustainable and inclusive economic growth

Easing ‘classroom crisis’ in Côte d’Ivoire, brick by (plastic) brick

The United Kingdom’s decision to leave the European Union will impact young people’s future the most

5 ways COVID-19 has changed workforce management

Parliament to ask for the suspension of EU-US deal on bank data

Coronavirus Global Response: European Commission pledges €300 million to Gavi

Trump’s MAGA policy remains unchanged as EU warns to impose additional retaliation tariffs on US products

European Defence Fund on track with €525 million for Eurodrone and other joint research and industrial projects

COVID-19 creates a perfect storm for the extreme weather season

Healthcare for refugees: a necessary symbiosis of medicine and politics

EU climate law: MEPs want to increase emission reductions target to 60% by 2030

A geared turbofan at Pratt & Whitney's production hub in West Palm Beach (copyright: Pratt & Whitney - a UTC Company- 2018; Source: Pratt & Whitney's website, media center)

The EU Commission approves UTC’s acquisition of Rockwell Collins under conditions

Slovakia and its failure to abide by the European law

How to help an ageing population stay wealthy for longer

Soil pollution ‘jeopardizing’ life on Earth, UN agency warns on World Day

“Beyond the beach: tackling plastic pollution upstream”, a Sting Exclusive by Erik Solheim, Head of UN Environment

Google’s bare truth: Europe’s Chief denies EU accusations but admits they “don’t always get it right”

FROM THE FIELD: Persons with disabilities bike towards sustainability

Our health systems are under pressure. Here are 9 ways to remedy that

Hardware is a cybersecurity risk. Here’s what we need to know

Hatred ‘a threat to everyone’, urges Guterres calling for global effort to end xenophobia and ‘loathsome rhetoric’

What talent means in the post-COVID-19 workplace

What will Germany look like after the next election?

New legislation on transparency and sustainability of the EU risk assessment model in the food chain

This woman changed the world of work – and you’ve probably never heard of her

‘Grave consequences’ await if new deadly escalation of violence in Gaza continues – top UN official

The Dead Sea is drying up, and these two countries have a plan to save it

African elephants under continued threat of poaching, warns UN-backed report

AIESEC Vlog

Four million have now fled Venezuela, UN ramps up aid to children who remain

Ercom, cutting-edge Telco solutions from Europe

As ride-hailing firms drive into the future, who is being left behind?

Syrian crisis: €5.3 billion mobilised by donors for 2021 and beyond at 5th Brussels Conference

Carnage must stop in northwest Syria demands Lowcock, as attacks intensify

New round of bargaining for the 2014 EU budget late in autumn

Sudan: European Union provides €30 million in humanitarian assistance

At last Germany to negotiate the costs for a really cohesive Eurozone

UN evaluates progress in improving peacekeeping performance

The US + Britain trivialize mainland Europe, NATO and the EU

Khashoggi case highlights ‘very worrying practice’ of overseas abductions, says UN expert

What does global health translate into?

How Costa Rica’s environment minister talks to his daughter about climate change

Polluted lungs: health in the center of environment discussion

Here are 3 lessons Europe can learn from China’s flourishing start-ups

Geopolitics and investment in emerging markets after COVID-19

Canada needs to increase foreign aid flows in line with its renewed engagement

EU Ombudsman investigates the European Commission

Coronavirus: EU global response to fight the pandemic

SCADA Security Conference 2017 in Prague, Czech Republic

Brexit: Six more months of political paralysis or a May-Corbyn compromise?

COVID-19 vaccination campaigns and their challenges

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s