IMF: Sorry Greece, Ireland, Portugal we were wrong!

International Monetary Fund's Managing Director Christine Lagarde (L) enjoys a visit in Malawi, meeting the colourfully dressed President of the country Joyce Banda (R) in Malawi, Jan. 4, 2013. (IMF picture library).

International Monetary Fund’s Managing Director Christine Lagarde (L) enjoys a visit in Malawi, meeting the colourfully dressed President of the country Joyce Banda (R) in Malawi, Jan. 4, 2013. (IMF picture library).

Sorry Greece, Ireland and Portugal says now the International Monetary Fund, we have grossly underestimated the negative effect on your economies, from our draconian austerity policies we recommended two years ago. This unbelievably blatant recognition, that the Fund, together with the EU Commission and the European Central Bank are applying wrong policies to the over-borrowed Eurozone countries, comes from the most competent source, the chief economist of the Fund and his deputy, Olivier Blanchard and Daniel Leigh.

The official authorisation from the IMF to distribute the report of the two authors came on 3 January 2013.Of course this confession is not officially recognised by the IMF. As the Fund comments, “the views expressed in this Working Paper are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent those of the IMF or IMF policy. Working Papers describe research in progress by the author(s) and are published to elicit comments and to further debate.”

Still those two guys are the brains behind IMF’s policies, which have sent half of Eurozone’s countries to an unseen before peace-time recession. Greece, Ireland, Portugal and soon to come to the club Spain and Italy are still under this wrong IMF recipe, which has being conclusively adopted by the European Commission, the European Central Bank and Berlin. At this point it must be reminded what was the cost to Greece from the policies the country was forced to apply by this troika of IMF, EU Commission and ECB.

The Sting recently wrote on this respect: “All along the last two and a half years Greece is under the “protection” of the troika of International Monetary Fund, the European Central Bank and the European Commission. Those three institutions theoretically are taking care of Greece’s financial problems, offer more loans and also dictate to the country’s government an economic policy mix of their choice including mainly draconian expenditure cuts. In this way ironically they managed to increase the country’s debt from 115% of the GDP in 2009, to 160% in November 2012. The reason was that the over the same period, Greece helped by troika, lost one-quarter of its Gross Domestic Product. This is by far the largest ever recorded loss of income and product in a developed economy in peacetime”.

In the case of Ireland and Portugal, the other two Eurozone countries which have being following similar programmes conceived by the troika, the negative effects were not that deeply devastating as in Greece, because those two countries apply a bit less tough austerity measures. The idea behind those programmes is to turn government budget deficits into surpluses in a very brief period of time.

The first recognition that the programmes were all wrong came last September, with the acceptance that the three countries need two more years to accomplish the draconian austerity targets set by the troika.  This was the direct outcome of the first hints by the IMF chief economist that the programmes are wrong, a confession made in Tokyo this summer by the writers of the report, during the annual conference of IMF and the Word Bank.

The confession

The two writers courageously recognise that they made mistakes. As they put it: “This paper investigates the relation between growth forecast errors and planned fiscal consolidation during the crisis. We find that, in advanced economies, stronger planned fiscal consolidation has been associated with lower growth than expected, with the relation being particularly strong, both statistically and economically, early in the crisis. A natural interpretation is that fiscal multipliers were substantially higher than implicitly assumed by forecasters. The weaker relation in more recent years may reflect in part learning by forecasters and in part smaller multipliers than in the early years of the crisis”.

In plain English the IMF says that they had grossly underestimated the negative effect of tough austerity and cuts of public spending on the economy. Reality showed that a larger than expected multiplier effect led to too much bigger losses of incomes and production in the three programme countries, as a result of the enforced by the IMF cuts in public spending.

Seemingly the Fund economists became conscious this summer of the huge extend of the damage and insisted that the other two members of the troika, namely EU Commission and ECB, also relax their demands from the three countries. The last to change attitude was Berlin, under heavy pressure from the IMF.

In any case Eurozone still follows the same recipe vis-à-vis the Eurozone countries needing financial support but the time horizon of the programmes to achieve fiscal consolidation have been extended by two years.

 

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Yemen: ‘No justification for this carnage,’ says UNICEF chief, as children in need now outnumber population of Switzerland

Environmental labelling, information and management schemes are central to the circular economy

How COVID could democratise commutes

At least half of people who have a job fear they’ll lose it in the next 12 months

How COVID-19 could open the door for driverless deliveries

“None of our member states has the dimension to compete with China and the US, not even Germany!”, Head of EUREKA Pedro Nunes on another Sting Exclusive

‘Crimes against humanity,’ ‘war crimes’ and risk of new ethnic violence in DR Congo, warn UN experts

EU industry: Commission takes action to improve synergies between civil, defence and space industries

Coronavirus (COVID-19) update: Busting the myth by looking at the facts

The world is failing miserably on access to education. Here’s how to change course

Human trafficking, slavery reports and health of migrants in Libya

Urgent action needed to address growing opioid crisis

The issue of mental health for modern young doctors

Link between conflict and hunger worldwide, ‘all too persistent and deadly’, says new UN report

How Eurozone consumers spend their income when they have one…

The countries most ready for the global energy transition

How the world can ‘reset’ itself after COVID-19 – according to these experts

UN experts decry torture of Rakhine men and boys held incommunicado by Myanmar’s military

34 million Americans know someone who died after being unable to pay for medical treatment

Germany caught with selfish double standards in euro area policy

Mergers: Commission approves Synthomer’s acquisition of Omnova, subject to conditions

Easing funding woes for UN agency assisting Palestine refugees a ‘wise investment for today and the future’

‘Foreign children’ in overwhelmed Syrian camp need urgent international help, says top UN official

“As German Chancellor I want to be able to cope with the merger of the real and digital economy”, Angela Merkel from Switzerland; the Sting reports live from World Economic Forum 2015 in Davos

7 simple steps we can all take to reduce food waste

‘Being open about my mental health created a better work culture’

5 myths about face masks under the microscope

COVID-19 is likely to increase youth unemployment in Africa, this is how business can mitigate the damage

This is why retail is such a sore point in India-US trade relations

Corporate tax remains a key revenue source, despite falling rates worldwide

Trust in OECD governments back at pre-crisis levels as governments seek to be more open and engaged

Coronavirus: Commission stands ready to continue supporting EU’s agri-food sector

Mental health in times of a pandemic: what can each individual do to lessen the burden?

A brief history of vaccines and how they changed the world

Quicker freezing and confiscation of criminal assets in the EU

Madagascar: UN chief commends nation on first round of peaceful elections

How trade tariffs could help combat climate change

Mental health in a pandemic: what to do to ease the burden on people with disabilities?

Home working has exposed us all to more cybercrime. Here’s how to close the breach

How we can win the war against antibiotic resistance

Globalization 4.0 must provide for the poorest, or it risks causing chaos for everyone

JADE Spring Meeting 2015: a step forward for Youth Entrepreneurship

Coronavirus: harmonised standards for medical devices to respond to urgent needs

Giving humanitarian help to migrants should not be a crime, say MEPs

This electric plane has flown successfully for 30 minutes – is this the future of flying?

Fighting crime: faster EU-wide exchange of non-EU nationals’ criminal records

3 challenges facing global gig economy growth after COVID-19

Neither side stands to benefit in US-China trade spat, UN says

‘InvestEU’ programme: big boost for jobs, growth and investment

Prospect of lasting peace ‘fading by the day’ in Gaza and West Bank, senior UN envoy warns

Virtual Doctor: a core part of modern healthcare?

“Asia-Pacific takes stock of ambitious development targets”, written by the Heads of UNFPA and ESCAP

Dozens of children at risk as clashes in Hudaydah near hospital – UNICEF

Click and Download: your app is ready to help you save lives

It’s time to stop talking about ethics in AI and start doing it

A new tidal energy project just hit a major milestone in Scotland

“Private” sea freight indexes hide Libor like skeletons?

Italy’s Letta: A European Banking Union soon or Eurozone collapses

The EU Commission predicts a decimated growth in the next years

‘Stay together and step up’ action to meet Global Goals, ECOSOC President tells development forum

More Stings?

Advertising

Comments

  1. Great article. The austerity measures in Portugal, although not as quite as Greece, had terrible effects in the economy and, most important, in people’s life. Anywhere you go, you only hear about crisis and debt… People are not living, they are surviving. We get a lot of criticism for spending too much, but only the ones that don’t have any fault are being crushed. There is a lot of unemployment, and it keeps rising to levels that are unbelievable. Anyway, it is sad and despairing to see my country like this. I’m leaving Portugal because I can’t find a job. A lot of young people is doing the same. This will lead to a lack of qualified professionals…
    The thing is: instead of focusing on reducing the debt, they should focus on the economic growth and then pay the debt.

  2. Some genuinely excellent articles on this web site , regards for contribution.

  3. The European governments should be looking at the unaccountability of the EU Commission , IMF , ECB etc and asking for change . If this is not done there will be more and more hostility to the EU by citizens and demands for referendums, with many people wanting their countries to leave the EU .
    The EU commission and council are contested more and more , especially with their inability to resolve problems , and the massive increase in unnecessary and complicated legislation increasing costs to companies.
    The One SIze Fits All ideas of the EU Commission has been proved not to work , and is one of the reasons for the EU problems . If one size fits all , then why are minimum wages not the same throughout the EU

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s