How pay transparency can help close wage gaps in the workplace

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Svenja Gudell, Chief Economist, Indeed Inc

• Even though pay transparency has risen overall in recent years, wide disparities still remain between countries and industries.
• US research shows that state and local regulations requiring pay disclosure can help boost adoption of the practice.
• More action is needed to close the wage gap and help job seekers negotiate equitable salaries.

Pay transparency – corporate disclosure of existing employees’ pay, along with the inclusion of wage and salary data in publicly advertised job postings – can help meaningfully reduce enduring wage gaps, especially along racial and gender lines. Enacting salary disclosure laws can be an effective tool for policy-makers keen on reducing inequality. But inconsistent global adoption of pay transparency practices threatens to keep pay inequality deeply entrenched in the global workplace.

In 2022, a female worker in the US could expect to earn just $0.82 for every $1 earned by a man, according to a recent analysis from Pew Research Center. Statistics from the US Department of Labor show that a Black worker in America earns only about $0.76 for every dollar a white worker earns – and that Latino workers earn just $0.73 to the dollar.

This pay inequity often begins with a starting salary and follows employees throughout their careers. Pay transparency can shift some salary negotiating power from employers to employees and candidates, helping eliminate conscious/unconscious hiring biases and forcing employers to be more accountable in implementing fair pay policies.

But while progress towards widespread pay transparency has been made in recent years, the majority of online job postings in the US and other countries still leave critical salary information unknown to would-be applicants. On their own, expanded regulations mandating pay transparency won’t immediately close persistent wage gaps. But research shows that even the threat of stricter transparency rules is enough to compel many firms to adopt the practice, especially as the persistence of remote work pushes employers in less-regulated areas to compete for workers living in more-regulated locales.

Pay transparency – measured here as the share of online job postings on Indeed that overtly advertise wage information – has risen steadily over the past three years, both in the US and other countries.

The share of US job postings on Indeed advertising employer-provided salary information more than doubled between February 2020 and February 2023, rising from 18% to 44%. The pay transparency rate in Germany over the same time increased from 8% to 20%. In Canada and France, the share of postings with salary information rose by 86% and 54%, respectively, between February 2020 and February 2023.

Line graph with five lines titled “Pay transparency is rising in many countries.” The graph has a vertical axis ranging from 0% to 50% and includes observations for Australia (AU), Germany (DE), Canada (CA), France (FR), and the United States (US). Indeed tracked the percentage share of job postings containing employer-provided salary information monthly from January 2019 to March 2023 The chart shows transparency rising across all displayed countries since 2020, but the increase is most pronounced in Germany, the US, and Canada. Source: Indeed.

A recent Indeed analysis of US job postings found that growth in pay transparency in job postings over the past few years can be attributed to several factors that are likely also present in other countries. Tight labour markets may be pushing some employers to be more forthcoming with salary information to attract more would-be applicants to open roles. The presence of salary information may also speed up the employer/employee matching process, especially in a tight market, by weeding out those would-be applicants who will not or cannot accept the salary offered. The rise and persistence of remote work may also play a role, with employers more compelled to broadly advertise salary information in hopes of attracting candidates living in areas where access to that data is expected and/or otherwise more commonplace.

Discover

How is the World Economic Forum promoting equality in the workplace?

The World Economic Forum’s Centre for the New Economy and Society shapes prosperous, resilient and equitable economies and societies. It takes an integrated approach to promote the new fundamentals of economic growth, good work standards, and better education; embed diversity, equity, inclusion and social justice in the new economy; and identify global risks.

• Through the Partnering for Racial Justice in Business initiative, the Forum is working with a global coalition of organizations committed to building equitable and just workplaces for professionals with under-represented racial and ethnic identities.
• The Forum’s Reskilling Revolution is preparing the global workforce with the skills needed to future-proof careers. The initiative is working with over 350 organizations to provide 1 billion people with better education, skills and economic opportunities by 2030.
• Since 2006, the Forum has been measuring gender gaps in countries around the world in the annual Global Gender Gap Report. The Forum has also helped to establish groups of accelerators focused on closing the economic gender gap in Chile, Argentina, Egypt, Jordan and Kazakhstan.
• Working with the Valuable500, the Forum is collaborating with the largest global network of CEOs committed to disability inclusion, making progress towards closing the disability inclusion gap.

Contact us for more information on how to get involved.

But the biggest likely driver of increased pay transparency, at least in the US, is the simple presence of laws requiring salary disclosure. In 2019, the state of Colorado passed legislation requiring employers to include salary information in job postings starting 1 January 2021. When the bill passed, only about 16% of US job postings provided salary information. Since then, California, Washington, and New York City have enacted similar requirements, with the rest of New York state expected to follow later this year.

And the laws appear to work – of the dozens of US metro areas included in this analysis, the 10 with the highest overall rates of transparency are all located in states covered by pay disclosure laws.

Even in areas without formal requirements for salary transparency, proximity to jurisdictions with transparency laws in place can be enough to spur meaningful progress. After removing states and cities with salary visibility laws in place, the three largest metro areas in Utah – which otherwise has no statewide transparency regulations – jump to the top of the list of most-transparent markets, perhaps a halo effect from Utah’s border with Colorado.

The potential of future regulation also appears to be enough to drive growth in transparency. The share of postings in Honolulu with salary information grew by 77% over the past year, even though Hawaii didn’t introduce a bill requiring pay disclosure until January. Transparency bills have also been proposed (but not yet passed) in Connecticut and Massachusetts, with similarly rapid growth in salary-transparent postings in markets in both states. Other metros on the list below are adjacent to states with active or proposed pay transparency legislation.

Finally, while the presence of or proximity to salary transparency laws can be enough to encourage more employers to embrace transparency, the opposite is also true: where there are no laws to compel transparency, transparency itself is diminished. Of the 20 US metros with the lowest pay visibility in postings, 18 are in the country’s south, where transparency regulation (and regulation overall) is typically lower than in other US regions. This trend still holds up, even accounting for differences in the types of jobs available in different regions.

More transparency is, on the whole, a good thing – even if a world where the exact pay for every job is known to anyone and everyone remains unrealistic. And the world can do a lot better, despite recent progress: the majority of Indeed job postings in the US, Germany, Canada and Australia, for example, still do not contain any salary information.

“Equal pay for equal work” is a noble goal that does not end at pay transparency but can certainly begin there. More really is more, and more access to more timely and more actionable data leads to more opportunities for more workers from more backgrounds, helping shift the balance of power in determining salaries toward the job seeker.