Why we can’t afford to dismiss carbon offsetting in a climate crisis

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Bronson Griscom, Senior Director, Natural Climate Solutions at Conservation International

  • We have 10 years to prevent irreversible damage to the planet due to climate change.
  • Despite this urgency, critical tools such as carbon offsetting, have been tarnished by claims of greenwashing.
  • We have a moral imperative to act now and harness the potential of carbon projects.

Given their potential, you’d think investments in nature would be a key priority? Well, you’d be wrong. Investments in nature represent just 3% of global finance dedicated to protecting the climate – a frustratingly small proportion.

As a scientist, I prefer to stick to data rather than debate questions of morality. Yet, I can no longer avoid wading into an argument that is consuming the environmental community. My fellow climate scientists tell us that we have about 10 years to reverse the growing concentration of greenhouse gases in our atmosphere or face catastrophe.

Carbon offsets, a critical tool for doing this, is hung-up in a dispute over whether offsets are just greenwashing. These criticisms resurfaced recently after UN Special Envoy on Climate Action and Finance Mark Carney detailed a blueprint for expanding the global carbon offsets market.

So, what are carbon offsets and what’s the debate about?

The idea is this: companies or individuals can buy and trade credits to offset a portion of their carbon emissions, with the revenue paid to landowners and communities as an incentive to protect and restore forests. This prevents emissions from deforestation – the second-leading cause of climate change – and absorbs the carbon in the atmosphere.

Land-based sinks in 1.5. pathways
Land-based sinks in 1.5. pathways Image: Griscom et al., 2017

The trouble is, some critics, many of them my fellow environmentalists, see these investments in nature as a license for corporations to pollute — moral hazards, they claim, that amount to greenwashing.

I can sympathize with this reasoning. Many corporations have assiduously worked against responsible climate and environmental policies, but that tide is turning.

Leading companies now acknowledge their foundational dependence on nature and a stable climate, and recognize the need to protect it by buying carbon offsets – a pragmatic and effective tool. Any further delay in deploying this tool will plunge humanity into a climate catastrophe of much greater impact. That’s the real moral hazard we face today.

What’s the World Economic Forum doing about deforestation?

Halting deforestation is essential to avoiding the worst effects of global climate change.

The destruction of forests creates almost as much greenhouse gas emissions as global road travel, and yet it continues at an alarming rate.

In 2012, we brought together more than 150 partners working in Latin America, West Africa, Central Africa and South-East Asia – to establish the Tropical Forest Alliance 2020: a global public-private partnership to facilitate investment in systemic change.

The Alliance, made up of businesses, governments, civil society, indigenous people, communities and international organizations, helps producers, traders and buyers of commodities often blamed for causing deforestation to achieve deforestation-free supply chains.

The Commodities and Forests Agenda 2020, summarizes the areas in which the most urgent action is needed to eliminate deforestation from global agricultural supply chains.

The Tropical Forest Alliance 2020is gaining ground on tackling deforestation linked to the production of four commodities: palm oil, beef, soy, and pulp and paper.

Get in touch to join our mission to halt to deforestation.

The science is clear. We must do two things to avoid a complete climate breakdown: dramatically reduce emissions and rapidly remove carbon that is already in the atmosphere. The vast majority of emissions cuts must come from ending the use of fossil fuels but we will not reach our emissions reductions goals without addressing deforestation, the second leading cause of climate change. High quality forest carbon projects provide the financing needed to ensure governments and local communities keep their forests standing.

In 2017, I published a study with colleagues which found that nature can deliver a third of the emissions cuts needed by 2030 to avert climate disaster. Not only do carbon offsets support natural climate solutions, like reforestation or the restoration of mangroves – the businesses that invest in them tend to take their climate commitments seriously.

Mitigation potential by ecosystem
Mitigation potential by ecosystem Image: Griscom et al. 2017

The CDP Climate Change Report 2016 found that companies that bought voluntary carbon credits also made more ambitious emissions cuts compared with companies that did not. Furthermore, despite the name, “offsets” are not just a one-to-one trade for dodging emissions cuts. Carbon trading brings in lower-cost options from nature, enabling much more climate mitigation “bang for the buck.” To be sure, carbon offset claims need to be verified. Fortunately, carbon verification systems have significantly improved.

Critics who remain unconvinced of the importance of carbon credits might consider how some local and underserved communities have benefited.

Success stories

A successful forest-carbon project in an area of the Peruvian Amazon that had some of the country’s highest deforestation rates has reduceddeforestation by 75%, resulting in the avoidance of more than 6 million tons of carbon emissions – the equivalent of taking more than 1 million cars off the road each year. Some 70% of the local community in this area benefitted from this programme through better healthcare and agricultural training.

Those benefits have real payoffs. Take Alto Mayo’s coffee crop – income provided by the carbon project has helped the local shade-grown coffee cooperative invest in productivity and quality, and establish access to new markets. Even as the pandemic has wrecked Peru’s economy, the cooperative’s exports grew by 50% in 2020 and since 2016 has earned $3 million dollars in revenue.

Another carbon offsets programme in California has seen more than 100 million credits traded to date, generating more than $500 million in revenue – with most of that going directly to local communities.

The government of Costa Rica, meanwhile, generates $30 million a year for forest conservation through the sale of carbon credits, and has conserved more than 2.5 million acres of its forests to date.

This is exactly why carbon offsets are so important: they create positive incentives that upend the conventional economic motivations that render tropical forests more valuable dead than alive. Increasing the demand for offsets can generate much needed action to test effective and socially responsible solutions, and scale them up globally through policy reforms.

In other words, carbon offsets are essential because they provide a simple way to keep, replenish and expand forests. Once a company or other entity has reduced their emissions as much as possible with existing technology, they can buy credits to deploy the most widely available but underfunded climate technology in existence, photosynthesis, thereby compensating for the environmental impact of energy sources such as jet fuel that do not yet have cost-effective alternatives.

Carbon offsets are not a silver bullet. They are no substitute for massive, comprehensive reductions in fossil fuel emissions. As with all innovative climate solutions, there have been successes, some of which I mentioned, and failures. We must be disciplined in learning from both.

Here’s the bottom line – the destruction of nature is the second largest driver of climate change, and we will not avert a climate crisis without investments that halt and reverse this destruction. We have a tool that does just that. To not use it is immoral.

The World Economic Forum’s effort to accelerate change

Unlocking large-scale carbon finance for nature, whether through voluntary or compliance action, requires close collaboration between governments, businesses, investors and civil society. The World Economic Forum and World Business Council for Sustainable Development co-convene the Natural Climate Solutions Alliance to bring together public and private stakeholders to identify opportunities and barriers to investment into carbon offsets in new and existing markets to increase financing for nature.

The NCS Alliance complements the work of the World Economic Forum’s Platform to Accelerate Nature-Based Solutions, where other projects like the Tropical Forest Alliance, 1t.org and Nature Action Agenda are fostering net-zero and nature-positive economies.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

ZTE @ MWC14: ZTE excels in all areas at this year’s Mobile World Congress

EU continues to address humanitarian needs in Ethiopia by allocating over €53 million

OECD tells Eurozone to prepare its banks for a tsunami coming from developing countries

More than four in 10 women, live in fear of refusing partner’s sexual demands, new UN global study finds

12 trade tasks to prioritize in 2021

Digitalising and modernising judicial cooperation: Council endorses provisional agreement reached with the European Parliament on service of documents and taking of evidence

PM May fosters chauvinism, declares trade war on Europe

12 ways the tech sector can help save the climate in 12 years

2019 data on official development aid & online discussion of ODA’s role in the Covid-19 crisis

Eurozone needs more than some decimals of growth

“Sorry mom it’s not our day”: the true refugee story of a young doctor and his family forced to flee their home

Lessons learnt, unlearnt or re-learnt? Analyzing the third wave of COVID-19

The European Parliament fails to really restrict the rating agencies

Infrastructural and system barriers to Universal Health Coverage: get in my patient’s shoes

Global Trade Identity can be the cornerstone of paperless trade

Focus on EU’s external action and building our stronger inner core: von der Leyen at the Special European Council

EU-US: A new transatlantic agenda for global change

Remittances could fall by $100 billion because of COVID-19 – here’s why that matters

Bangladesh, South Africa and Bolivia all beat the US for women’s representation in politics

COP24 negotiations: Why reaching agreement on climate action is so complex

Artificial intelligence summit focuses on fighting hunger, climate crisis and transition to ‘smart sustainable cities’

Commission proposes action to uphold child rights and support children in need

“We need to use the momentum globally to ensure that corporations pay their fare share of taxation”, EU Commissioner Valdis Dombrovskis outlines from the World Economic Forum 2017.

Europe votes against GMOs but the Council votes for TTIP

The South China Sea Arbitration: Illegal, Illegitimate and Invalid

3 ways to use digital identity systems in global supply chains

Pakistan: UN strongly condemns terrorist attack that leaves scores dead and wounded at election rally

Statement by Executive Vice-President Margrethe Vestager on State aid measures to address the economic impact of COVID-19

Commission publishes the first report on the issuance of a Eurobond

4 ‘big bets’ to close the post-pandemic gender gap

Building cybersecurity capacity through benchmarking: the Global Cybersecurity Index

Insurer CEOs Reveal Marketing Strategies that Communicate the True Value of Insurance Products & Services to the Customer

Governments should step up their efforts to give people skills to seize opportunities in a digital world

State aid: Commission approves €200 million Danish loan in support of the Travel Guarantee Fund for travel cancellations due to coronavirus outbreak

‘Once-in-a-generation opportunity’ will be squandered, warns Guterres, unless social, economic, environmental challenges are met

EU free-trade agreements with Canada and US: imagine the fallout if put to national referendums

Liaison Officer – 2020

How the coronavirus market turmoil compares to 2008 – and what we can do

EU fundamental rights under threat in several member states

Pandemic declared as infections slow in China. Today’s 7 coronavirus updates

France-Germany: Divided in Europe, USA united in…Iran

Knowledge management and entrepreneurship: short term vs. long term perspective

Employment and Social Developments in Europe review: why social fairness and solidarity are more important than ever

Iran nuclear talks’ deadline extended: the match is still open for many

Supercomputing could solve the world’s problems, and create many more

Reading the smoke signals: The long-term consequences of Amazon wildfire on global health

How a new approach to meat can help end hunger

Commission adopts Recommendation on EU coordinated approach to travel and transport in response to new variant of coronavirus in the UK

The time for cities to get smart is now

Here’s what global progress on COVID-19 vaccination looks like

Air pollution: How to end the deaths of 7 million people per year?

A Europe that protects: EU customs seized over 31 million fake goods at EU borders in 2017

Banning out-of-hours work emails could make some employees more stressed, research finds

Making technology work for 1.3 billion Indians

Mental health apps: Help is just within a pocket reach

Coronavirus response: Commission welcomes agreement on crucial VAT relief for vaccines and testing kits

Conference on the Future of Europe: Engaging with citizens to build a more resilient Europe

How to reimagine our cities as hubs for biodiversity, conservation and climate resilience

JADE Handover Ceremony at the European Parliement

We can end TB right now. Here’s how

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s