Mergers: Commission fines Canon €28 million for partially implementing its acquisition of Toshiba Medical Systems Corporation before notification and merger control approval

canon

(Dollar Gill, Unsplash)

This article is brought to you in association with the European Commission.


The European Commission has fined Canon, the Japan-based imaging and optical products manufacturer, €28 million for implementing its acquisition of Toshiba Medical Systems Corporation (TMSC) before notification to and approval by the Commission, in breach of EU Merger control rules.

Commissioner Margrethe Vestager, in charge of competition policy, said: Companies have to respect our competition rules and procedures. They are obliged to notify and wait for our approval before a merger can go ahead. Canon structured a transaction to circumvent these obligations when they acquired TMSC. This is a procedural breach of our merger review so we are fining Canon €28 million. Our merger assessment and decision-making depends on the Commission being sure that companies are not jumping the gun and implementing mergers without our approval.”

EU merger control provides a quick and efficient one-stop shop for companies.

To be able to deliver accurate decisions within tight timelines, the EU merger control system is built on clear procedural rules that companies must fully respect.

EU merger rules require that merging companies notify planned mergers of Union dimension for review by the Commission prior to their implementation (“the notification requirement”) and do not implement them until notified to and cleared by the Commission (“the standstill obligation”). The notification requirement safeguards the Commission’s ability to detect and investigate mergers. The standstill obligation prevents the potentially irreparable negative impact of transactions on the market, pending the outcome of the Commission’s investigation.

On 12 August 2016, Canon notified the Commission of its plan to acquire Toshiba Medical Systems Corporation (“TMSC”) from Toshiba. The transaction was unconditionally cleared by the Commission on 19 September 2016.

For the acquisition, Canon used a so-called “warehousing” two-step transaction structure involving an interim buyer.

As a first step, the interim buyer acquired 95% in the share capital of TMSC for €800, whereas Canon paid €5.28 billion for the remaining 5% of the shares and share options over the interim buyer’s stake. This first step was carried out prior to notification to or approval by the Commission.

As a second step, following approval of the merger by the Commission, Canon exercised its share options, acquiring 100% of the shares of TMSC.

In July 2017, the Commission addressed a Statement of Objections to Canon detailing its concerns that, through the transaction structure put in place for its acquisition of TMSC, Canon had implemented the acquisition before notifying it to the Commission and obtaining approval under EU merger control rules.

In November 2018, the Commission addressed a Supplementary Statement of Objections to Canon, complementing the preliminary view taken in the Statement of Objections and reflecting developments in the case law.

In today’s decision, the Commission confirms its preliminary view that Canon breached the EU Merger Regulation and fines the company €28 million.

In particular, the Commission has concluded that:

  • The first and second steps in the transaction structure formed together a single notifiable merger. The first step contributed to the acquisition of final control over TMSC, which occurred with the second step. In fact, within the structure chosen by the companies, the first step was necessary for Canon to gain control over TMSC.
  • By carrying out the first step, Canon partially implemented its acquisition of TMSC before both the notification and the Commission’s approval. As a result, Canon breached the notification requirement and standstill obligation.

Today’s decision has no impact on the Commission’s decision to authorise the transaction under the EU Merger Regulation. The assessment of the Commission at the time was independent of the facts reproached by the Commission to Canon in today’s decision.

 

The fine

According to the EU Merger Regulation, the Commission can impose fines of up to 10% of the aggregated turnover of companies that intentionally or negligently, breach the notification and/or the standstill obligations.

In setting the amount of a fine, the Commission takes into account the nature, the gravity and duration of the infringement, as well as any mitigating and aggravating circumstances.

Canon breached both the notification requirement and the standstill obligation. The Commission considers that both these infringements are serious because they undermine the effective functioning of the EU merger control system.

Moreover, the Commission considers that Canon was aware of its obligations under the EU Merger Regulation. Therefore, Canon’s breach of procedural obligations was, at least, negligent. The fact that the transaction was cleared unconditionally is also taken into account for the gravity of the infringements.

On the basis of these factors, the Commission concluded that an overall fine amount of €28 million is both proportionate and deterrent.

 

Background

Other merger procedural cases

In April 2019, the Commission imposed a €52 million fine on General Electric for initially providing incorrect information during the investigation of its planned acquisition of LM Wind. This decision had no impact on the Commission’s approval of the transaction under EU merger rules, as this was based on rectified information from the second notification.

In February 2019, the Commission sent a Statement of Objections to Telefónica Deutschland alleging the company breached commitments it offered to secure the Commission’s approval of its acquisition of E-Plus in 2014.This investigation is ongoing.

In April 2018, the Commission imposed a €124.5 million fine on Altice, the multinational cable and telecommunications company based in the Netherlands, for implementing its acquisition of the Portuguese telecommunications operator PT Portugal before notification or approval by the Commission.

In July 2017, the Commission sent a Statement of Objections to Merck and Sigma-Aldrich, alleging they breached EU merger rules by providing incorrect or misleading information in the context of their merger. This investigation is ongoing.

In May 2017, the Commission fined Facebook €110 million for providing incorrect or misleading information during the Commission’s 2014 investigation of its acquisition of WhatsApp. This decision had no impact on the Commission’s October 2014 approval of the transaction under the EU Merger Regulation, since the clearance decision was based on a number of elements going beyond those linked to the incorrect or missing information.

Procedural background

The obligation on companies to notify concentrations with Union dimension to the Commission prior to their implementation is laid out in Article 4(1) of the EU Merger Regulation. This obligation safeguards the Commission’s ability to detect and investigate concentrations.

The standstill obligation, which is set out in Article 7(1) of the Merger Regulation, establishes that concentrations falling within the remit of the Merger Regulation may not be implemented prior to notification to or clearance by the Commission. This obligation prevents the potentially detrimental impact of transactions on the competitive structure of the market, pending the outcome of the Commission investigation.

The ability of the Commission to impose fines in the event of a breach of Articles 4(1) and/or 7(1) is laid out in Article 14(2)(a) and (b) of the EU Merger Regulation.

More information will be available on the competition website, in the Commission’s public case register under the case number M.8179.

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

100 years on, UN labour agency mission focussed on growing inequality, says Director-General

Better air pollution data is helping us all breathe easier. Here’s how

Zimbabwe ‘facing worst hunger crisis in a decade’

Women’s rights face global pushback from conservativism, fundamentalism – UN experts warn

Alcohol abuse kills three million people a year, most of them men – WHO report

The EU moulds a new compromise for growth and financial sustainability

G20 LIVE: World Leaders in Turkey for G20 Summit. Global Economy will be discussed in Antalya

Time to pay up: UN summit to push for development finance breakthrough

Encouraging progress made in 2018, in ‘zero tolerance’ effort to end sexual exploitation and abuse across UN

‘Beyond reasonable doubt’, international court convicts notorious DR Congo rebel leader of war crimes

Data Protection Regulation one year on: 73% of Europeans have heard of at least one of their rights

Why responsible consumption is everyone’s business

Aid spending fell in 2018, for the second year in a row

Scientists have created biodegradable microneedles to fight eye disease

France is about to start giving free breakfasts to disadvantaged schoolchildren

Food finally features in the climate debate. Now what?

Fuel crisis rapidly draining last ‘coping capacities’ of Palestinians in Gaza

Visa Facilitation and Readmission: the European Union and Belarus sign agreements

Eurozone’s bank resolution mechanism takes a blow

The cost of healthcare is rising in ASEAN. How can nations get the most for their money?

“Who do I call if I want to call Europe?” Finally a name and a number to answer Henry Kissinger’s question

Secretary-General calls for global participation in UN75 dialogues for better future for all

‘BioSolar Leaves’ are better at cleaning the air than trees, say the technology’s developers

MWC 2016 LIVE: Ford trumpets new in-vehicle system, “fundamentally rethinks” transportation

How drones can help rural Africa take flight

Walk, cycle, dance and play – UN health agency recommends new action plan for good health

16 foods that are good for you – and the planet

EU to finance new investment projects with extra borrowing; French and Italian deficits to be tolerated

Member states jeopardising the rule of law will risk losing EU funds

Eurobarometer survey: Majority of EU citizens positive about international trade

Car bomb attack on National Police Academy in Colombia, ‘strongly condemned’ by UN

Conditions deteriorating alarmingly in Yemen, warns senior UN official

New EU rules to thwart money laundering and terrorist financing

Sudan: UN rights chief alarmed over ‘excessive force’, alleged use of live fire against protestors

Migration and rule of law on next ACP-EU Parliamentary Assembly agenda

Medicine in the 4th Industrial Revolution: the third entity of the new doctor-patient relationship

To save biodiversity, MEPs call for binding targets at global and EU level

A reflection of health inequity in recent epidemics

UNESCO food and culture forum dishes up fresh serving of SDGs

#EUBeachCleanUp: EU organises record number of cleaning actions worldwide

IQ scores have been falling for decades, new study finds

From start-up to scale: This is how governments can accelerate innovation and build inclusive economies

Nigeria: Armed conflict continues to uproot thousands, driving up humanitarian need

How TV has brought mental health issues into the light – and helped to banish stigma

The two big uncertainties shaping our future

Millennials are transforming African farming

4 key ways countries can finance their SDG ambitions

Professional practices of primary health care for Brazilian health and gender inequality

A Europe that protects: EU reports on progress in fighting disinformation ahead of European Council

An economist explains how to value the internet

This NATO experiment used fake Facebook accounts to trick soldiers into sharing sensitive information

Dealing with stress among healthcare professionals: are we missing the elephant in the room?

External action: more funds for human rights, development and climate change

International trade statistics: trends in third quarter 2019

Syria: Urgent, concrete actions needed, to protect children too young to ‘make sense of this senseless war’

Brexit: Six more months of political paralysis or a May-Corbyn compromise?

UNICEF chief hopes 2020 will be ‘a year of peace’ for Syria’s children

Food supply chain: A step closer to ending unfair trading

UN chief praises New Zealand premier’s ‘admirable’ response to Christchurch attacks

Lifting the lid on the value of a company’s human capital

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s