Why cities hold the key to safe, orderly migration

Migration 2018

Children play football outside a residential block in Sixth of October City outside Cairo. Many of the Syrians arriving in Egypt have found places to stay here. © UNHCR/S.Baldwin

This article is brought to you thanks to the strategic cooperation of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Harald Bauder, Professor of Geography and the Director of the Graduate Program in Immigration and Settlement Studies, Ryerson University, Toronto & Loren Landau, South African Research Chair for Mobility & the Politics of Difference, African Centre for Migration & Society, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg

Migration is largely an urban phenomenon. According to the 2018 World Migration Report, “nearly all migrants, whether international or internal, are destined for cities”.

Cities respond very differently to migration. Many cities are supportive, boost the rights of migrants and reap the benefits of migration. The mayors of these municipalities are frequent panelists and speakers, extolling the virtues of migration, and proudly proclaiming that the future of migration is local. Other cities, however, seek to restrict migration and actively exclude migrants from social, economic and political participation.

This dual role poses a challenge to the implementation of the United Nations’ ambitious agenda, presented in the Global Compact for Safe, Orderly and Regular Migration. The Global Compact for Migration, as it’s also known, is an intergovernmental agreement on multiple dimensions of international migration; this agreement is expected to be adopted by the vast majority of UN member states in December 2018.

Image: 2018 World Migration Report

In support of migration, the mayors of major migrant destination cities, such as New York, Chicago and Los Angeles, are standing up against national policies that treat migrants unfairly and deny them rights and services. In January of 2017, New York’s Mayor Bill de Blasio proclaimed that “we’re going to defend our people regardless of where they come from, regardless of their immigration status”. With this proclamation, De Blasio reaffirmed New York’s status as a sanctuary city that protects the city’s most vulnerable inhabitants.

Cities in other countries pursue a similar approach. In 2013, the Canadian city of Toronto declared itself a sanctuary city, inspiring other Canadian cities to follow suit. Cities like Barcelona in Spain or Quilicura in Chile pursue a similar approach, although they don’t call themselves sanctuary cities but a “Refuge City” and “Commune of Reception” respectively.

Although African cities have been notably missing in many of the global debates on refugee support or migrant integration, they too are stepping tentatively on to the stage. Although often constrained by highly centralised financial and political authorities, they are exploring options for building services that can accommodate mobility in all its forms. Arua in northern Uganda, for example, has embraced its role as a destination for migrants and refugees from South Sudan. The Cities Alliance is now working with “secondary cities” across Asia, Africa and Latin America to find ways to incentivize similar responses.

These cities are assuming responsibility in addressing and reducing the vulnerabilities in migration, which is one of the key goals of the Global Compact for Migration. They commit to providing basic services for migrants, and seek to ensure that migrants receive access to these services free of discrimination, based on race, gender, religion, national or social origin, disability or migrant status.

However, cities can also play a darker role in the migration process. As a set of institutions closely connected to a local political constituency, cities are often more responsive to popular attitudes than more distant national administrations are. Where there are strong pro-migrant business, religious or civic bodies, cities may embrace mobility. But this is not always the case. Indeed, some migrant-receiving cities are enacting restrictive local policies in an effort to repel newcomers and drive out migrants already living within their municipal borders. In 2006, the Pennsylvania town of Hazelton pioneered – albeit ultimately unsuccessfully – this type of local policy by making it more difficult for irregular migrants to rent housing or get employment in the municipality. In Canada, the Quebec town of Hérouxville took a swipe at Muslim migrants by introducing a “code of conduct” in 2007 that, among other measures, prohibited the stoning of women. Other cities simply passively comply with or support national immigration raids and exclusions.

African cities are not immune to creating hostile environments for migrants. The mayor of Johannesburg, Herman Mashaba, has been accused of anti-migrant tactics and announced earlier this year that he will actively cooperate with national authorities in conducting immigration raids. In Nairobi, authorities have cooperated with national police in rounding up Somali refugees, even while turning a blind eye to a range of other international migrants living in the city. Other municipal or sub-municipal authorities across Africa have also actively and sometimes violently moved to exclude outsiders. Sometimes these are refugees and international migrants. Sometimes they are migrants from within their own countries.

These cities are, in fact, increasing the risks and vulnerabilities migrants face, counteracting the intentions of the Global Compact for Migration.

Cities around the world encounter diverse situations as migrant destinations, transit hubs or places of departure; they have different histories and find themselves in different geopolitical situations; some cities are richer and others are poorer; and cities in different countries possess different levels of autonomy from national and regional governments.

What is clear, however, is that the successfully implementation of the Global Compact for Migration requires the cooperation of cities.

Cities that lack a strong local pro-migration constituency will require incentives to be inclusive of migrants. Such incentives might involve financial support and access to resources and programmes from national and international bodies. Enhancing local authority and participation can ironically make it more difficult for local authorities to fight for unpopular refugees and migrants. Global norm-setting can help counter such moves, but advocates and authorities also need to operate more quietly, stealthily incorporating refugees and migrants into their programmes across sectors. Indeed, migration policy per se is likely to offer few protections if local policies for housing, employment, education, commerce, trade and planning do not consider mobility.

As recent as 2015, William Lacy Swing, the director-general of the International Organization of Migration (IOM), lamented at the Conference on Migrants and Cities that “city and local government authorities have so far not had a prominent voice in the global debates on human mobility”. This situation is changing. Cities increasingly assert their voices and are recognizing that they are key partners in tackling the challenges of migration.

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

‘Terminator’ warlord Bosco Ntaganda sentenced to 30 years in prison for DR Congo atrocities

EU trade agreements: delivering new opportunities in time of global economic uncertainties

EU Budget 2019: MEPs increase funding on youth, migration and research

Council strongly criticised over failing to act to protect EU values in Hungary

The two big uncertainties shaping our future

Draghi will not hesitate to zero ECB’s basic interest rate

A Sting Exclusive: “Paris is the moment for climate justice”, Swedish MEP Linnéa Engström claims from Brussels

What the future of trust looks like

IMF’s Lagarde: Ukraine must fight corruption

Ship Recycling is the Commission’s Titanic

Migration: Better travel safe than sorry

Chart of the day: This is how many animals we eat each year

Can Argentina’s new president save the country’s economy?

Top UN officials sound alarm as Yemen fighting nears vital hospital in port city of Hudaydah

What lies ahead for the Korean Peninsula?

Ebola outbreak in DR Congo declared over, now let’s tackle other health challenges: WHO chief

Missile strike kills at least 12 civilians, including children, in Syria’s Idlib: UN humanitarians

This farmer used an age-old technique to save his soil and now his farm is prospering

FROM THE FIELD: Survival in Yemen against all odds

ICC Appeals Chamber acquits former Congolese Vice President Bemba from war crimes charges

Superbugs: MEPs advocate further measures to curb use of antibiotics

From cheeseburgers to coral reefs, the science of decision-making can change the world

The issue of mental health for modern young doctors

Chart of the day: These countries have the highest share of electric vehicles

UN agriculture agency chief calls on world’s mayors to make ‘global commitments local realities’

We can build a carbon-neutral world by 2050. Here’s how

These cities have the best quality of life

Crucial medical supplies airlifted to north-east Syria to meet ‘desperate need’

Human rights on film: International festival celebrates mobile phone films for a cause

Russia can no longer be considered a ‘strategic partner’, say MEPs

FROM THE FIELD: Argentina Preserving Pristine Forests

EU elections: Can EU citizens’ awareness eradicate fake news more efficiently than Facebook, Twitter and Google?

Poor Greeks, Irish and Spaniards still pay for the faults of German and French banks

Children who exercise have more brain power, finds study

7 ways business can be agents for peace

UN envoy commends successful conclusion of Guinea-Bissau presidential election

Safe drinking water, sanitation, are ‘basic human rights’: new UN Water Development report

5 ways the world is rallying around Australia as bushfires rage

Why we need a moderate approach to moderating online content

The EU banking union needs a third pillar guaranteeing deposits

The cost of healthcare is rising in ASEAN. How can nations get the most for their money?

We can meet the SDGs using the wisdom of crowds. Here’s how

The ECB again takes care of the bankers not the people

Turkey caught in a vicious Syrian circle bringing terror and war at home

How our food system is eating away at nature, and our future

These tech start-ups are changing what it means to farm

This is how much the US-China trade war could cost the world, according to new research

EU-US trade deal: Europe to Americanize its social model?

Main results of EU Environment Council, 25/06/2018

OECD Steel Committee concerned about excess capacity in steel sector

Jo Cox’s murderer believed the ‘leave’ campaign leaders that the ‘remain’ vote is treason

Can a Bavarian Oktoberfest beer indulger bring down the Berlin government?

The European Commission and EU consumer authorities publish final assessment of dialogue with Volkswagen

Hiring more female leaders is good for profits. Here’s the evidence

A 3-step plan for carbon-neutral cars

Press coverage of migration crisis in Europe: a call for collaborative action

Is academia losing its chance to capitalize on technology?

Global warming: our responsibility

Where EU air pollution is deadliest

To hope or doubt? The state of women’s progress in the world

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s