Draghi joined Macron in telling Germany how Eurozone must be reformed

French President Emmanuel Macron delivered a momentous speech after receiving the Charlemagne Prize. Sited behind Macron, ECB President Mario Draghi a former laureate of the Charlemagne Prize, looks on. Aix-la-Chapelle, 11 May 2018. (French Presidency work – snapshot from a video).

Mario Draghi the President of ECB, speaking at the European University Institute in Florence, on 11 May 2018, must have been under the influence of the idealistic aura of this Florentine learning institution. He went as far as proposing political policies, bravely overstepping his role as central banker of Eurozone. Draghi asked for an effective “European deposit insurance scheme”. He also proposed the creation of “an additional fiscal instrument to maintain convergence during large shocks” in Eurozone.

Those are two clearly set ideas. The first is about a credible and adequately financed common euro area bank deposit guarantee scheme. The second one is tantamount to a Financial Ministry and minister in Brussels, with a macro-economically important budget. Both proposals are identical to Emmanuel Macron’s ideas about how to reform and save the European Union. The French President reiterated and amplified his well known proposals on 10 May in Aix-la-Chapelle, while receiving the Charlemagne Prize in front of an audience comprising Angela Merkel and other top European leaders. This time, Macron didn’t chew his words and told the German Chancellor, who was sitting just a few meters from him, what her country must do. Let’s take one thing at a time.

The Italian banking crisis

Returning to Florence, we find Draghi asking for the creation of a true ‘Banking Union’ with a powerful Single Resolution Fund (to resolve failing banks), backed by the financial powers of all the sovereign governments of euro area, including the one based in…Berlin. Currently, this Fund is financed by small annual contributions paid by the lenders, being overtly incapable of confronting a real banking crisis, but this arrangement is totally inadequate and cannot save even the smallest bank. During the last three years, this was evident in the case of Italy.

During that period, Italy, despite been over-indebted, was forced to alone save a number of failing banks. In this way the Italian government dived deeper into debt and consequently was unable to adequately support economic growth. This had devastating effects on the country’s political developments. The result is an impossible government, being currently about to be formed by the ‘5 Star Movement’ party led by a comedian, plus the anti-European, extreme right populists of ‘Lega’. All of them promised greener grass, to win the 4 March elections.

They will end up blaming Europe for their treachery and the failure to honor promises. Politically then, it’s not an exaggeration to predict that Italy’s future in the euro area is at stake. Such a dreadful prospect may trigger the unravelling of the entire euro money block.

An effective backstop

Obviously, this is what Draghi wanted to avoid, when he said “What is still missing, however, is a backstop for the Single Resolution Fund. That is why in all the other large jurisdictions, such as the US, the UK and Japan, resolution funds are backstopped by the fiscal authority”. He expertly identified here a critical deficiency of Eurozone. Clearly, the euro area lacks a real banking union, with a dependable risk sharing mechanism, backed by all member states’ financial resources.

If such a mechanism existed, it would have reduced the country risk for all and every member state. In 2014, Germany blocked the enactment of such a powerful financial instrument, by compromising the Single Resolution Fund. As the Fund was finally shaped in June of that year, currently, it cannot handle in an orderly and low cost way the resolution of any bank.

What is missing?

Undeniably, if there was a common EU and strong fiscal authority and a euro area bank deposit guarantee system in Brussels, the Italian banking crisis would have cost much less. By the same token, it wouldn’t have produced today’s political stalemate, which may prove to be a bomb in the foundations of Eurozone and the EU.

Germany is the only economic power which blocked the creation of such a pan-European and effective Single Resolution Fund. In 2014, Berlin opposed the creation of such a Fund, fearing that it will be only Germany to pay for it. Now however, Macron says France is ready to undertake the proportionately right part of the financial burden to mend that, so Germany cannot go on stubbornly using this argument.

France can fund it

Last week in Aix-la-Chapelle, the French leader said it clearly, speaking after he received the prestigious Charlemagne Prize. He stated, “C’est pourquoi je crois dans un budget européen beaucoup plus ambitieux, dans lequel la France prendra sa part de contribution…défendre une convergence économique, fiscal… C’est pour cela que je crois à une zone euro plus forte, plus intégrée, avec un budget propre permettant les investissements et la convergence parce que c’est le seul moyen de permettre à tous les États qui souhaitent aller de l’avant, d’aller en cette direction”. (“That’s why I believe in a much more ambitious European budget, for which France is to undertake her contribution…to defend an economic, fiscal convergence…That’s why i believe in a much stronger euro area, more integrated, with its own budget which will support investments and convergence because this is the only means to open the way to all member states who wish go forwards, to go in this direction”).

He had more to say though. Macron also pointedly said that the German surpluses are the deficits of somebody else and this cannon go on: “en Allemagne, il ne peut pas y avoir un fétichisme perpétuel pour les excédents budgétaires et commerciaux parce qu’ils sont toujours faits aux dépens de certains autres”. (“In Germany, the ongoing fetishism for budget and trade surpluses cannot go on any more, because they are always accumulated on certain other people’s expenses”).

At the expenses of others

Every year, Germany turns out a trade surplus of some tens of euro billions with her EU partners. Unfortunately, she hoards those colossal funds and refuses to recycle them. Thus in the long run, this country inhibits the entire euro area’s economic system from functioning properly. Actually, Germany neutralizes the abilities of her trade partners to grow. The political side effects have been evident in the periphery of Eurozone. During the past few years one after the other Italy, Greece, Spain, Portugal and Ireland have been politically functioning on the brink of the abilities of their party systems.

As noted in the introduction, Draghi completed his vision for Europe, proposing also the creation of a common pan-European fiscal instrument, he said … “such an instrument (a Eurozone budget) could take: from the provision of supranational public goods – like security, defense or migration – to a fully-fledged fiscal capacity”. It may not be by chance that with a difference of a few hours -10 May for Macron, 11 May for Draghi – the two proposed detailed and identical reforms about how the Eurozone can avoid being wasted away in a few years. Each of them explained what is needed to be done, the way they knew best; Macron in political terms and Draghi with solid economic reasoning.

The question remains though, if they can force Germany to accept the reality that Eurozone cannot go on creating surpluses only for this country.

 

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

EU to Turkey: No other ties than €3+3bn to upkeep refugees

Alcohol abuse kills three million people a year, most of them men – WHO report

More urgency needed to help increasing numbers ‘locked out’, before 2030, says UN’s Bachelet

1st Exclusive High Level Dialogue: China-EU Cybersecurity and 5G Cooperation

Hungary: people born in the 2020s won’t have legal rights any more to buy tobacco

New EU guidance helps companies to combat forced labour in supply chains

European Young Innovators Forum @ European Business Summit 2014: Europe for StartUps, vision 2020

EU approves €100 million for the post-earthquake reconstruction in Albania

JADE at European Business Summit 2015

From Russia with love: Brussels and Moscow close to an agreement on Ukraine’s gas supplies

Schools in Florida now have to teach mental and emotional health

4 ways to make your wardrobe more sustainable

VAT: New e-commerce rules in the EU will simplify life for traders and introduce more transparency for consumers

More taxpayers’ money for the banks

“What a Wonderful World”: the unsettled relationship between Climate Change and Human Health

Rule of law in Poland: MEPs point to “overwhelming evidence” of breaches

Devastating storms like Hurricane Florence ‘unusual this far north’: UN weather agency

COP21 Breaking News_03 December: Unprecedented Global Alliance for Buildings and Construction to Combat Climate Change

International Literacy Day: What you need to know about youth literacy

SPB TV @ MWC14: The TV of the Future

Stage set for successful 2020 Burundi elections, Foreign Minister tells General Assembly

Are the G20 leaders ready to curb corporate tax-avoidance?

Decisive international action needed to end Israeli occupation: UN rights expert

Tax and fiscal policies central to governments’ responses to Covid-19 crisis

Foreign Affairs Council (Trade) of 22/05/2018: EU relations with key trading partners

4 ways to cyberproof your business during mergers & acquisitions

How can we maximise the benefits of a system value approach?

Protests, violence in Haiti prompts international call for ‘realistic and lasting solutions’ to crisis

Security Council hails ‘historic and significant’ joint peace declaration by Ethiopia and Eritrea

EU Directive makes haircut on uncovered deposits a standard in bank bail-ins

Conflict prevention, mediation: among ‘most important tools’ to reduce human suffering, Guterres tells Security Council

How a new encryption technique can help protect privacy amid COVID-19

5 things you probably didn’t know about global health

The EU Commission openly repudiates the austere economic policies

New UN forestry project bids to help countries meet climate change commitments

Global Citizen-Volunteer Internships

Is the EU competent enough to fight human smuggling in 2015?

EU food watchdog: more transparency, better risk prevention

UN General Assembly President upholds value of multilateralism in speech closing annual debate

Remarks by Ambassador Zhang Ming at a Virtual Event Marking the 100th Anniversary of the Founding of the Communist Party of China

From Trials to Vials: Ensuring an Equitable Distribution of COVID-19 vaccines

European Solidarity Corps: three years on

Replacement for United States on Human Rights Council to be elected ‘as soon as possible’

Encouraging progress made in 2018, in ‘zero tolerance’ effort to end sexual exploitation and abuse across UN

From inconvenience to opportunity: the importance of international medical exchanges

Smart cities must pay more attention to the people who live in them

EU fundamental rights under threat in several member states

We need to deep clean the oceans. Here’s how to pay for it

Cross-border travel is confusing after COVID – this framework can help borders reopen safely

6 charts that show how Japan’s economy stacks up as it enters a new era

Gender equality: Parliament strives to be frontrunner among EU Institutions

Consumer protection: Commission revises EU rules on product safety and consumer credit

EU agricultural production no more a self-sufficiency anchor

Why an evidence-driven approach is the best way for businesses to support workplace mental health

‘All atrocity crimes are preventable’ and can never be justified – UN chief

Five years down the drain

This is how COVID-19 is affecting informal workers

5 libraries doing innovative things to help their communities

Why the future of food must be blue as well as green

European Green Deal: Commission presents actions to boost organic production

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s