It’s time to ditch our obsession with trade deficits. Here’s why

Arancha González Laya 2018

(International Trade Centre, 2013)

This article is brought to you based on the strategic cooperation of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Arancha González Laya, Executive Director, International Trade Centre.

The notion that trade surpluses are a measure of a country’s economic prowess dates back centuries. In 16th-century Europe, “mercantilists” from England to Venice sought to accumulate gold by promoting exports and discouraging imports. Their intellectual heirs today think trade surpluses boost national welfare, employment and economic growth, while deficits do the opposite.

The preoccupation with surpluses is based on dubious arithmetic: since one country’s exports are another’s imports, it is impossible for all countries to be net exporters. It also overlooks a more fundamental point about trade. The main benefit from trade is imports – foreigners sending the fruits of their labour for us to enjoy, allowing us to focus on what we do best. Working to produce exports is the price we pay to enjoy these benefits.

A better goal is to reduce the export effort needed to obtain a given quantity of imports. Economists call this “enhancing the terms of trade”. This makes intuitive sense in our own lives: you run a surplus with your employer in order to run deficits with your local grocery store, your daughter’s football league and your favourite restaurant. Now imagine if you could run those same deficits while spending only half as much time at the office.

Adam Smith recognized in 1776 that the true wealth of a nation was not the gold and silver in its coffers, but the productivity of its labour force. “Nothing can be more absurd than this whole doctrine of the balance of trade,” he wrote. Fast-forward to the present day, and his warning is once again going unheeded by policy-makers. Erecting protectionist barriers is unlikely to create jobs and prosperity, for two reasons.

 Three ways of looking at the US trade deficit with China (as % of GDP)

Three ways of looking at the US trade deficit with China (as % of GDP)
Image: Oxford Economics

First, current measures of trade on the basis of flows give a distorted view of bilateral trade balances, since they fail to account for components imported to make exported goods. Given the fragmentation of production across multi-country value chains, a far better gauge of a country’s trade performance is how much value it adds to inputs. Focusing exclusively on goods exacerbates the misperceptions since it excludes trade in services, which typically accounts for more than two-thirds of output in advanced economies.

Second, there is no straightforward relationship between a country’s trade balance and its economic health or labour-market dynamics. For example, US job creation since the 1990s has been fastest during periods when imports were growing rapidly. The trade balance narrowed dramatically in 2009 – mainly because GDP growth and job creation were plummeting due to the financial crisis, shrinking demand for imported goods and services. Germany has big trade surpluses rather than deficits, but manufacturing’s share of total employment there has been declining at more or less the same pace as in the US.

Percentage of employment in manufacturing in the US and Germany

Manufacturing jobs in the US and Germany
Image: US Bureau of Labor Statistics

Third, a country’s trade surplus or deficit is shaped less by the content of its trade agreements – tariff levels, quotas, regulatory rules and so on – than by the balance between domestic saving and investment within its own economy. Take the European Union: the entire bloc has exactly the same trade policy. Yet its member states perform very differently.

 Current account balance for European Union member states, as % of GDP, 2017

Current account balance for EU states, as % of GDP, 2017
Image: Eurostat

The current account balance – a broad measure of trade in goods and services that also includes net flows of income from foreign investments – is fundamentally a function of national saving and investment. Countries that run deficits spend more on imports than they earn from exports and borrow from the rest of the world to make up the difference. Conversely, surplus economies earn more from exports than they pay for imports; they lend the difference abroad, accumulating claims on foreigners in the process.

The only way to shift the current account balance is to alter savings and investment behaviour by households, firms and governments. Trade protectionism is an indirect way to accomplish this – but it could well miss the target or even backfire. For instance, when a country taxes steel imports, it hurts the export competitiveness of domestic makers of cars, planes, and anything else containing the metal.

Cross-country evidence suggests no clear link between tariff protection and current account balances. If anything, higher-tariff countries tend to have larger trade deficits. The World Trade Organisation rulebook authorizes countries to take protective action against import surges or predatory pricing, but while such measures can fight unfair trade, they have little effect on overall trade deficits.

Trying to tackle trade deficits bilaterally won’t work. Balancing trade with individual countries would, in practice, require constant interference with the purchase and sales decisions of thousands of companies and households, raising prices and generating distortions. Imagine if your supermarket had to buy something from you before it could sell you food.

None of this means policy-makers should ignore the existence of large trade surpluses and deficits. The cross-border financial flows these macro-economic imbalances entail are vulnerable to sudden stops that can destabilize countries and the global economy, as many Asian countries learned in 1997, followed by the Eurozone a decade later. But the solution is not trade restrictions: it lies in international cooperation to get countries that over-save to encourage more spending, and countries with big deficits to tighten their belts when circumstances allow it. The group of 20 leading nations is the logical forum in which to do just that. Similarly, broad negotiations among a number of countries are the most effective way to address unsatisfactory trade rules and industrial overcapacity.

Popular discontent over trade springs from genuine problems. Market-opening agreements have amplified technological trends that deliver outsized gains to small numbers of individuals, firms and regions. Closing markets solves none of these, but would hurt voters’ purchasing power, destabilize businesses and weaken future productivity.

Governments need to develop policies and institutions that cushion the blow from changes brought by both competition and technology, constrain runaway inequality, and equip people and businesses of all sizes to share in the opportunities presented by the global economy. This is the real challenge in trade. Current-account balances are merely a distraction – albeit one that could prove costly indeed.

Advertising

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

UN General Assembly: Here are the 5 big summits to watch for

DR Congo: Following second brutal assault on Ebola clinic, UN health chief vows to continue serving ‘most vulnerable’

This heroic doctor is waging war on rape and the stigma around it

“Only through energy policy we can trigger competitiveness”. The Sting live from #EBS2015: Energy Union – When will it happen?

Here’s what I learned at Davos 2020

Youth2030: UN chief launches bold new strategy for young people ‘to lead’

UN calls for funds to ease ‘deteriorating’ humanitarian situation in Gaza and West Bank

Armenia should take vigorous measures against entrenched corruption

Artificial Intelligence raises ethical, policy challenges – UN expert

Closing VAT loopholes for sales through online platforms

Investors have a role in securing our shared digital future

Pakistan: a long road ahead

Rural women a ‘powerful force’ for global climate action: UN Secretary-General

The MH17 tragedy to put a tombstone on Ukrainian civil war

Human rights breaches in Nigeria and Burundi

10 ways cities are tackling the global affordable housing crisis

It’s time we took a seat ‘at your table’: Guterres calls on world youth to keep leading climate emergency response

Latest Coronavirus (Covid-19) briefing from the World Health Organisation – key takeaways

How cities can become more resilient to climate change

The Sting’s Mission

Education remains an impossible dream for many refugees and migrants

Humanity ‘at a crossroads’ as damage to planet poses growing risk to health, UN environment agency warns

Engaging women and girls in science ‘vital’ for Sustainable Development Goals

Plastic Oceans: MEPs back EU ban on polluting throwaway plastics by 2021

First-ever global conference of national counter-terrorism chiefs will strengthen cooperation, build ‘resilient’ States, says top UN official

UN chief pays tribute to ‘enduring contributions’ to regional, international diplomacy of Oman’s late Sultan Qaboos

My Mothers

Managing and resolving conflicts in a politically inclined group of team members

Global South cooperation ‘vital’ to climate change fight, development, Guterres tells historic Buenos Aires summit

Prisoner executions in Belarus ‘simply unacceptable’, says UN rights body

Kellen Europe Hosts EuroConference 2016

2021-2027 EU Budget: €378,1 billion to benefit all regions

COP21 Breaking News_03 December: Unprecedented Global Alliance for Buildings and Construction to Combat Climate Change

EU summit: Are the London Tories planning an exit from the EU?

UN ‘regrets’ new US position on legality of Israeli settlements

Here’s how businesses can make the circular economy a reality

We need natural solutions to fight ocean and climate risk

5 ways blockchain can transform the world of impact investing

Dangers of poor quality health care revealed ‘in all countries’: WHO report

Mergers: Commission clears Vodafone’s acquisition of Liberty Global’s cable business in Czechia, Germany, Hungary and Romania, subject to conditions

3 things to know about our Sustainable Development Impact Summit

Not faith, ‘but those who manipulate the faithful’ driving wedge between religions, UN-backed forum in Baku told

‘Health is a right, not a privilege’ says WHO chief on World Health Day

Violence on the rise in Darfur following Sudan military takeover, but UN-AU peacekeeping mission maintains ‘robust posture’

Europe turns out more jobs this summer

Climate change hits the poor hardest. Mozambique’s cyclones prove it

From sun-powered trikes to mind-controlled TV – 10 top gadgets unveiled at CES 2020

The EU Commission vies to screen Chinese investment in Europe

This robot boat delivered a box of oysters in a breakthrough for unmanned shipping

Brexit: European Commission recommends the European Council (Article 50) to endorse the agreement reached on the revised Protocol on Ireland / Northern Ireland and revised Political Declaration

Security Council renews Central African Republic arms embargo

Beware the fragility of the global economy

‘Vaccines are safe’ and save lives, UNICEF declares, launching new #VaccinesWork campaign

How drones can manage the food supply chain and tell you if what you eat is sustainable

Managers’ pay under fire

Indonesian tsunami death toll climbs over 400 as Government-led relief efforts are stepped up

Catalan Pro-Independence vote: how many hits can Brussels sustain at the same time?

COP21 Paris: The Final Agreement Adopted-full text

UNICEF warns of ‘lost generation’ of Rohingya youth, one year after Myanmar exodus

Youth unemployment: think out of the box

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s