Brexit talks: 2nd round fails to bring the EU and the UK closer on key issues


Michel Barnier, the EU’s Chief Negotiator and David Davis, British Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union, hold a joint press conference at the end of the second round of Brexit negotiations. (Copyright European Union / Source: EC – Audiovisual Service)

After millions of words that have been said over the matter, last week, the time for a concrete evaluation of the progress of Brexit negotiations came. Last Thursday, the European Union and the United Kingdom concluded the second round of Brexit talks, which was seen to be as the full conclusion of the first leg of negotiations and was regarded as the litmus test of the general progress of the works. And, despite negotiators of both sides said days before the talks kicked off they would work to identify both “their differences and their similarities”, it seems that they made good progress just on the former.

Background

When last month the negotiators of the EU and the UK met for the first official round of the Brexit talks, after the United Kingdom triggered Article 50 of the Lisbon Treaty, the objective of the meeting was only to agree on the “organisation of the negotiations”, as repeatedly said by all key players involved. When the second round came closer though, it seemed clear that both sides had higher objectives and they wanted to bring home some substantial progress. At the start of the meeting, Monday last week, Britain’s Brexit minister and veteran anti-EU campaigner David Davis said it was “time to get down to work and make this a successful negotiation”, and the EU’s chief negotiator Michel Barnier said, “we will now delve into the heart of the matter”, before the two sat down for a first meeting.

“Fundamental divergences”

However, despite such determined approach, it seemed immediately clear after the end of last week’s talks that the two parts are far from reaching an agreement. As soon as the second round of negotiations came to an end, on Thursday, both negotiating teams have recognized there are still “fundamental” differences on key disputes, including issues on citizens’ rights and the Irish border. Most notably, EU’s chief negotiator Barnier, despite recognizing “some progress” has been made, said there was “a fundamental divergence” on how to protect the rights of EU citizens living in Britain and of Britons in the remaining 27 EU countries after Brexit. “Any reference to European rights imply their oversight by the Court of Justice of the European Union,” he told a joint news conference with British Brexit Secretary David Davis.

Citizens’ rights

The citizens’ rights is indeed where the main differences between the EU and the UK remain after last week’s meetings. Both negotiators from the EU and UK stressed they want an early and detailed deal to protect the rights of nearly 5 million citizens that today live on this or that side of the “post-Brexit barricade”, which is actually one of the trickiest points of discussion. The most complicated aspect is indeed the right to move around, the right to work and to to export social benefits after Great Britain leaves the bloc. If no compromise will be found, the risk for 3.5 million EU nationals in the UK and 1.2 million British people on the continent is that there will be no freedom of movement and no real protection while working abroad.

EU’s negotiator Barnier repeatedly reinforced the EU’s message that that any future disputes over citizens’ rights be adjudicated by the European Court of Justice, which at the moment is a total no-go for UK’s Prime Minister Theresa May. “In the withdrawal agreement itself, citizens must be able to find the legal certainty that they need in their day-to-day lives,” Mr. Barnier said. “Quite frankly, as far as we are concerned we can see no other way in which can guarantee the permanent continuation of such European rights as exercised. Clearly any reference to European rights implies their oversight by the courts of justice of the European Union”, he added. UK’s chief negotiator Davis responded: “We agree on the need for certainty on the part of citizens both in the EU and the UK. We obviously have different views on how we achieve that”.

Exit bill

Another area of disagreement surely was the financial one, with the “divorce bill” being the hottest topic. Michel Barnier immediately called for clarity on the British position on the financial settlement. “I know one has to compromise in negotiations but we are not there yet”, Mr. Barnier said. “A clarification of the UK position is indispensable for us to negotiate and for us to make sufficient progress on this financial dossier, which is inseparable from the other withdrawal dossiers”, he also added. The EU’s position in such a crucial matter is that Britain needs to agree a “single financial settlement”, as often stated by EU negotiators, covering debts and unpaid bills after more than four decades of membership. “We know that agreement will not be achieved through incremental steps. As soon as the UK is ready to clarify the nature of its commitments, we will be prepared to discuss this with the British negotiators”, EU’s Barnier also commented last week.

The UK’s “obligations”

The British side acknowledged for the first time last week they have “obligations” to the EU, while uncertainty persisted over the size of such obligations and more. “On financial settlement we both recognise the importance of sorting out the obligations we have to one another, both legally and in a spirit of mutual cooperation”, said UK’s David Davis. “We had robust but constructive talks this week. There is a lot left to talk about, and further work before we can resolve this”, Mr. Davis also added. However, during the Q&A at the end of last Thursday’s conference in Brussels, Mr. Davis refused to give any fresh evidence of the government’s willingness to compromise, as also reported by the Guardian. The EU executive has quantified the exit bill to be in a region of 60 billion euros ($70 billion).

Easy deal

What failed to receive any special mention and probably to gain momentum during last week’s sessions was the trade agreement between the two parts in the post-Brexit era. However, British international trade minister Liam Fox said last week he was convinced a trade deal with the EU should be “one of the easiest in human history” to reach, although his country could survive without one if necessary. The comments from the Cabinet Minister came as Brexit Secretary Davis wrapped up last week’s meetings with his EU counterparts, and only weeks after Mr. Davis described his job as more difficult than working for the space agency NASA.

Indeed Mr. Fox, while on an interview with BBC Radio 4’s “Today” programme, downplayed the importance of securing a free trade deal with Brussels, and argued that Britain could manage even without any deal, if negotiations collapsed and the UK was forced to leave without an agreement. On the reasons why reaching an agreement with the bloc would be so easy, Fox said: “We are already beginning with zero tariffs, and we are already beginning at the point of maximal regulatory equivalence, as it is called. In other words, our rules and our laws are exactly the same”.

Future talks

The two sides published a joint traffic lights report at the end of last week’s round of talks, to show progress on 44 separate issues of contention and coloured them according to how advanced the state of play is. Out of 44 separate issues, the report shows there is an agreement on 22 “green areas” while severe disagreements on 14 “red” issues exist and as many as 8 “amber” areas that need further clarification remain. Now the next round of talks is set for August 28, where progress on questions such as Northern Ireland and its borders with the Republic of Ireland is expected to be made. But, despite high hopes and expectations, Mr. Davis clearly said last week we “shouldn’t expect incremental progress in every round”.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Are ECB’s €500 billion enough to revive Eurozone? Will the banks pass it to the real economy?

Italy’s rescue operation Mare Nostrum shuts down with no real replacement. EU’s Triton instead might put lives at risk

What happens when you toss your water bottle in the trash?

The hidden risk of virtual reality – and what to do about it

The world needs a grand coalition to tackle climate change

Bill Gates: How HIV/AIDS prepared us to tackle COVID-19

Child victims of DRC Ebola outbreak need ‘special attention and care’: UNICEF

Sudan military committed to ‘ensuring stability’ and ‘peaceful transition’ says senior diplomat, as UN rights chief appeals for protesters’ rights to be upheld

How revealing the cost of coal makes us all better off

A safer, more dignified journey for all migrants, tops agenda at global conference in Marrakech

Missions of Our Time Shared by China and EU

MEPs vote to limit negative impact of no-deal Brexit on citizens

A jingoistic Spanish ‘war’ from the past

UN agencies call for more resettlement and end to detention of asylum seekers in Libya

These 11 companies are leading the way to a circular economy

Easing ‘classroom crisis’ in Côte d’Ivoire, brick by (plastic) brick

LETTER FROM AFGHANISTAN: Elections serve up food for thought, for Afghan youth

Traffic congestion cost the US economy nearly $87 billion in 2018

Portugal wants its emigrants back – so it’s paying them to return

Here’s how to rebut the climate doom-mongers

Space science now a ‘fundamental pillar’ of 21st century human development: top UN space official

EU consumer rules: Airbnb cooperates with European Commission and EU consumer authorities improving the way it presents offers

Commission puts in place transparency and authorisation mechanism for exports of COVID-19 vaccines

Medical students of today, technological doctors of tomorrow

We need to rethink the way we heat ourselves. Here’s why

EU Top Jobs summit ended with no agreement: welcome to Europe’s quicksand!

Central Africans ‘need our help now’: UN’s deputy relief chief

The EU spent €158 billion on vague, open-ended rural projects

The 4 types of leader who will thrive in the Fourth Industrial Revolution

Algorithmic warfare is coming. Humans must retain control

FROM THE FIELD: Hardy seeds bear fruit to protect Colombia’s environment

UN envoy commends successful conclusion of Guinea-Bissau presidential election

Refugee crisis update: EU lacks solidarity as migration figures drop

Thursday’s Daily Brief: Safeguarding civilians, strengthening Ebola response in DR Congo, marking Fistula Day, updates on CAR and Syria

UN and partners call for solidarity, as Venezuelans on the move reach 4.5 million

Billions for sustainable investments – Germany’s plan for a green recovery

A Sting Exclusive: “Cybersecurity: Why consumer products must be looked at urgently”, by BEUC’s Deputy Director General

The 28 EU leaders don’t touch the thorny issues

Migration crisis update: lack of solidarity not only among EU leaders but also EU officials

UNICEF urges all countries to provide ‘Super Dads’ with paid leave

EU long-term budget deal must be improved for Parliament to accept it

Heart attacks and strokes are more common on high pollution days, data shows

As Syria conflict enters ninth year, humanitarian crisis ‘far from over’, Security Council hears

Brexit Preparedness: European Commission adopts final set of “no-deal” contingency measures for Erasmus+ students, social security coordination rules and the EU budget

Technophobe or technophile? We need more conversation about digital transformation

This is how we can empower 8 billion minds by 2030

Shifting Tides: Policy Challenges and Opportunities for the G-20

Kazakhstan continues to push for a nuclear-free world

Turkey needs to step up investment in renewables to curb emissions

New UN Global Climate report ‘another strong wake-up call’ over global warming: Guterres

Accountability for atrocities in Myanmar ‘cannot be expected’ within its borders – UN investigator

How AI is shaping financial services

Coronavirus: Commission holds first meeting of EU COVID-19 national scientific advice platform

Connect 4 Impact – a virtual journey around the globe WSA Global Congress 2021 – March 22-24

Merkel, Mercedes and Volkswagen to abolish European democracy

Coronavirus: Using European supercomputing, EU-funded research project announces promising results for potential treatment*

How can we make enough vaccine for 2 billion people?

At last a solid base for the European Banking Union

Let Nagasaki remain ‘the last city’ to suffer nuclear devastation says museum director, as UN chief arrives

Trump systematically upsets global order and trade: Where does this end?

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s