EDRi @ European Business Summit 2014: Digital Citizenship in Brussels – the case of Net Neutrality

Participation of Neelie Kroes, Vice-President of the EC, at the seminar "Women on top", organised in Amsterdam (EC Audiovisual Library)

Participation of Neelie Kroes, Vice-President of the EC, at the seminar “Women on top”, organised in Amsterdam (EC Audiovisual Library)

Written by Joe McNamee, Executive Director of European Digital Rights (EDRi)

Net neutrality is a digital rights issue, par excellence. The internet has created huge opportunities for the exercise of freedom of communication, for freedom of assembly and for democracy. These opportunities have the same roots as the huge economic success of the internet: openness. The internet allows anyone to connect to anyone without discrimination. Ideas – political, social or business – become global phenomena at a speed that would be unthinkable without this openness.

This openness has been preserved in a telecommunications market that exists because of regulation. Starting from the old national telecoms monopolies 25 years ago, the EU prised the markets open with a series of major liberalisation packages, supplemented with targeted interventions (such as on roaming and local loop unbundling) whenever it became clear (or, to be more precise, about two years after it became clear) that the natural anti-competitive tendency of network industries started kicking in.

In this context, it is somewhat funny, although you do have to admire their cheek, to listen to representatives of former monopolies furrow their collective brows and talk in hushed tones about the “dangers of over-regulation” and the “risks to investment” in infrastructure if net neutrality is protected by law. These protestations are even more amusing when we consider that the telecoms industry lobbied against pretty much every pro-competitive measure, ostensibly due to fears about network investment – fears that subsequently proved unfounded. This is an industry that is as successful as it is because political leaders largely ignored this nonsense and pushed competition into a market that gravitates towards anti-competitive behaviour.

As an alternative to this “over-regulation” that they claim to fear, the former monopolies propose a complete re-invention of how traffic flows over the internet. They have suggested a “sending party pays” model – where they can charge any online service for “sending” traffic to their customers – even though, it is quite obvious that their customers actively choose (and pay to choose) to download content rather than it being passively sent to them. In other words, they suggest creating a new monopoly, where access to their customers becomes the product. Instead of an open internet, we would have a closed, unpredictable “internet”. Individuals would pay to connect to the internet and “the internet” would pay to connect to them!

The telecoms operators explain that competition would act as a safeguard, because customers can change from one operator to another if they are not getting access to the right services. And, if you have never tried to change from one access provider to another, you might be inclined to believe this. However, what about if you are trying to get investment for an innovative new EU-wide online service in this new market? You have to explain to the bank that, at any given moment, you could lose access to half of the market to any given country, unless you pay the dominant telecoms operator whatever ransom they decide to charge to permit access to its customer base. The damage to innovation would be disastrous.

Ultimately, less innovation will lead to less compelling online content and services, leading to less demand for high-quality services, to the detriment of the entire online economy, and to the detriment of the telecoms companies. However, the destruction of net neutrality would come at an even greater cost – namely free speech. The internet has flourished because the EU, following the example of the USA, has established provisions to make sure that, within strict limits, internet companies cannot be held iable for illegal content to which they unknowingly provide access to. In EU jargon, they cannot be held liable if they are acting as a “mere conduit” to the content in question.

If the telecoms providers are deciding what their customers can gain access to – particularly if using surveillance methods such as “deep packet inspection” – they will no longer be able to claim that they are “mere conduits”. This will inevitably lead to policy-makers demanding that they should be more liable for what is accessed by their customers. It will also lead to more court injunctions that will seek to use the expanded technical capacities of telecoms companies to identify and block traffic on their networks. Already this year, we have seen the European Court of Justice rule that crude, non-specific injunctions can be imposed on telecoms companies to “take reasonable measures” (“reasonable” will change in meaning as technical capacities develop) to prevent access to specific content or websites.

So, instead of “over-regulation”, the telecoms companies campaign in favour of a restructuring of the internet. They campaign for a restructuring that would destroy the vibrant nature of online service provision, to the detriment of citizens and business, including the telecoms companies. They campaign for a restructuring in the knowledge that this will come at the cost of a significant increase in legal liability, leading to an increase in surveillance, blocking and filtering. Still, that’s better than over- regulation, apparently.

EDRi believes that the openness of the internet is what has generated the amazing tools that citizens now have at their fingertips to communicate, to campaign and to organise. We believe that the environment that generated this innovation must be maintained. We believe that the legal protections of the businesses that facilitate the exercise of our online freedoms must be preserved.

European Digital Rights (EDRi) is an association of 36 digital rights organisations from 21 countries. We campaign to defend citizens’ rights in the online environment.

Joe McNamee is Executive Director of European Digital Rights, where he has worked since 2009. He holds Master’s Degrees in European Politics (Wales) and International Law (Kent). His first job in the internet sector was as a senior technical support adviser for an internet access provider in 1995. Prior to joining EDRi, he worked in a telecoms consultancy where he ran three independent research projects for the European Commission – on local loop unbundling, telecoms/internet convergence and information society markets in eight former Soviet states. 

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Featured Stings

andrus-ansip-tweet-data-privacy

EU is now giving Google new monopolies to the detriment of European citizens and Internet companies

European Parliament. Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs (ECON) meeting: ‘Monetary Dialogue with the President of the European central bank. Mario Draghi (third from right), Roberto Gualtieri (S&D, IT) chair ECON Committee (in the middle), Sander Loones (ECR, BE) (first from right), Pablo Zalba-Bidegain, (EPP, ES) (first from left). (European Parliament Audiovisual Services, Event Date: 12/11/2015, City: Brussels, Bergium, Copyright: © European Union 2015 - Source : EP).

Draghi tells the Parliament the ECB to use all its weaponry; euro slides to parity with the dollar

Press conference by Joaquín Almunia, Vice-President of the European Commission, on the launch of the consultation on the new state aid rules, (EC Audiovisual Services).

ECB is about to lend trillions to banks

From left to right Dan Mullaney, Chief US Negotiator for the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP), and Ignacio Garcia Bercero, Chief EU Negotiator for the TTIP, opened last month the eight round of the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) talks, in Brussels (EC Audiovisual Services, 06/02/2015)

“Leaked” TTIP document breaks post 8th negotiations round silence and opens door to critics

Jean-Claude Juncker, Prime Minister; Minister of State; Minister of Finance of Luxembourg, José Manuel Barroso, President of the EC,  Herman van Rompuy, President of the European Council and Christine Lagarde, Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) (from left to right). (EC Audiovisual Services).

Eurozone officials play with people’s deposits and minds

Algirdas Šemeta, Member of the European Commission in charge of Taxation, Customs, Statistics, Audit and Anti-Fraud, gave a press conference to present the details of the Financial Transaction Tax (FTT), which will be implemented under enhanced cooperation. As requested by the 11 Member States that will proceed with this tax, the proposed Directive mirrors the scope and objectives of the original FTT proposal put forward by the Commission in September 2011. (EC Audiovisual Services).

The EU Parliament endorses tax on financial transactions

ANTALYA, TURKEY - NOVEMBER 14 : Chinese President Xi Jinping arrives at the Antalya International Airport for the G20 Turkey Leaders Summit on November 14, 2015 in Antalya, Turkey. The 2015 G-20 Leaders Summit will be held in Antalya on November 15-16, 2015. Okan Ozer / Anadolu Agency

G20 LIVE: “International communities and leaders have great expectations for 2016 G20 summit in Hangzhou China”, Mr Wang Xiaolong, the Chinese Foreign Ministry’s special envoy stresses live from G20 in Antalya Turkey

A hearing at the European Court of Justice (European Court of Justice, 2010)

EU Court of Justice invalidates Safe Harbour and the game for thousands US businesses suddenly changes

Benoît Cœuré, Member of the Executive Board of the European Central Bank (ECB), participating in the conference "Financial Stability and the Single Market – The Keys to Growth in Europe". (EC Audiovisual Services).

ECB: Growth measures even before the German elections

YOUTH RIGHTS AT RISK FROM RISE OF EXTREME-RIGHT AND POPULISTS IN THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT

Ukraine, Kiev, Maidan Square; General view of the square. Shoot date: 13/05/2014. (European Council Newsroom).

Moscow’s Eurasian Union lost significance after the crisis in Ukraine

Mr Macron seems very happy thinking he has the blessings of the EU. Elżbieta Bieńkowska, Member of the EC in charge of Internal Market, Industry, Entrepreneurship and SMEs, received Emmanuel Macron, French Minister for Economy, Industry and Digital Sector earlier in November (EC Audiovisual Services, 6/11/2014)

France pushes UK to stay and Germany to pay

The Container Terminal of the Piraeus Port

The success story of a Chinese investment in the Greek port of Piraeus

José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission (in the centre), Olli Rehn, Vice-President of the EC in charge of Economic and Monetary Affairs and the Euro (on the left), and Michel Barnier, Member of the EC in charge of Internal Market and Services, gave a joint press conference on the blueprint for a deep and genuine Economic and Monetary Union (EMU). (EC Audiovisual Services).

Predicting two more years of economic stagnation

zte_logo

ZTE @ MWC14: ZTE excels in all areas at this year’s Mobile World Congress

aidex 2015 logo

AIDEX 2015: Humanitarian Hero Award Winner Announced

The British Prime Minister David Cameron bites its lips. Wonder why?

EU summit: Are the London Tories planning an exit from the EU?

Press conference by Michel Barnier, Member of the European Commission in charge of Internal Market and Services on the adoption by the EC of a draft regulation on benchmarks, (EC Audiovisual Services, 18/09/2013).

The EU lets the bankers go on rigging the benchmarks

diana

Diana in Vietnam

Vytenis Andriukaitis, EU Commissioner responsible for Health and Food Safety. © European Union , 2016   /  Source: EC - Audiovisual Service   /   Photo: Lieven Creemers.

“Access denied”: the Greek health system under pressure

Alexis Tsipras World Economic Forum 2016 Davos

WEF Davos 2016 LIVE: “It is the implementation, Stupid!”, German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaueble points the finger to Greece from Davos

European Youth Vlog

Angela Merkel, German Federal Chancellor, Mario Monti, Italian Prime Minister and Minister for Economy and Finance ad interim, and José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission (from right to left). (EC Audiovisual Services).

South Eurozone countries threatened by rising borrowing cost and expensive euro

Opening of the "European Space Expo" in London by Antonio Tajani, Vice-President of the European Commission. There he pronounced a speech entitled "European Space Solutions". (EC Audiovisual

Is Eurozone heading for disinflation?

G20 ministers of Finance and central bank Governors' meeting in Russia, on 16 February 2013, (G20 Russian Presidency, photographic library).

G20 to Germany: Abandon miser policies

Frans Timmermans, First Vice-President of the EC in charge of Better Regulation, Inter-Institutional Relations, the Rule of Law and the Charter of Fundamental Rights, Valdis Dombrovskis, Vice-President of the EC in charge of the Euro and Social Dialogue, and Corina Creţu, Member of the EC in charge of Regional Policy, went to Riga where they participated in a debate about the future of Europe at the "Riga Latvian Society House". The event was hosted by the first Latvian Presidency of the Council of the EU. (EC Audiovisual Services, 08/01/2015).

Are ECB’s €500 billion enough to revive Eurozone? Will the banks pass it to the real economy?

Olli Rehn, Vice-President of the EC in charge of Economic and Monetary Affairs and the Euro, received Artur Mas, President of the Generalitat de Catalunya. This handshake that happened exactly one year ago probably made most Catalans believe that they can make ends meet on their own (EC Audiovisual Services, 30/09/2013)

Scotland “shows the way” to separatist movements as Catalonia calls a vote on independence

EU Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors focussed their attention on the Banking Union, financing SMEs and the EU economic outlook on the first day of the Informal ECOFIN meeting in Vilnius. (Lithuanian Council Presidency , photographic library 14/9/2013)

Eurozone’s bank resolution mechanism takes a blow

Marine Le Pen

The scary EU elections result and the delayed Council’s repentance

Internet of Things MWC16

MWC 2016: IoT experts fret over fragmentation

Androulla Vassiliou Member of the EC in charge of Education, Culture, Multilingualism and Youth (speaking on the microphone), participated in the Summit on Skills and Education, 'Saving Europe's Lost Generation', organised by the Friends of Europe. (from left to right) Frank Vandenbroucke, Professor at the Research Centre of Public Economics at KU Leuven Androulla Vassiliou, Giles Merrit, Secretary-General of Friends of Europe, Karen Coleman, journalist and broadcaster for the Irish Independent newspaper, Massimiliano Mascherini, Research Manager at Eurofoundand Andrea Gerosa founder of ThinkYoung. (EC Audiovisual Services, 15/05/2013).

Eurozone cannot endure any longer youth marginalisation

Original drawings by Albert Rocarols on the theme of the euro. (EC Audiovisual Services)

Appreciation of euro to continue

He is Alone and Ready to release the Greek bomb! Mr Yanis Varoufakis, Finance Minister of Greece at yesterday's ECOFIN Council in Brussels (EU Council TV Newsroom, 17/02/2015)

D-Day for Grexit is today and not Friday; Super Mario is likely to kill the Greek banks still today

Photo taken outside the House of Commons on 20 June 2016. Hundreds of people have showed their sorrow and paid tribute to the tragic loss of Jo Cox's life. This photo was taken by the European Sting during its London coverage of the EU referendum (The European Sting, 20/06/2016)

The IMF sees Brexit’s ‘substantial impact’ while the world’s economy holds its breath

Connie Hedegaard, Member of the EC in charge of Climate Action, gave a press conference following the 2011 compliance round-up on emissions trading. (EC Audiovisual Services)

The EU pollution rights trading system frozen

Eurogroup meeting - March 2015. The 19 Eurozone finance ministers meet on 9 March 2015 in Brussels. The President of ECB Mario Draghi (on the left) participates regularly in these meetings. In this instance he talks with the Jeroen Dijsselbloem, President of the Eurogroup. (European Council - Council of the European Union Photographic Library, 9/3/2015).

More billions needed to help Eurozone recover; ECB sidesteps German objections about QE

Opening of the photo exhibition entitled ‘I Am Not a Statistic’ organised at the European Parliament, with the participation of Johannes Hahn, Member of the European Commission at the rostrum. (European Commission Audiovisual Services, Date: 30/06/2015, Location: Brussels – European Parliament).

How close is Eurozone to a new recession which may trigger formidable developments?

Dan Mullaney, Chief US negotiator (on the left) and Ignacio Garcia Bercero, Chief European Union negotiator for the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP), held a second round of talks in Brussels from Monday 11 to Friday 15 November 2013. (EC Audiovisual Services 15/11/2013).

EU Commission – US hasten talks to avoid NGO reactions on free trade agreement

Press conference by Neelie Kroes, Vice-President of the EC, on the Net Neutrality. (EC Audiovisual Service)

The big five EU telecom operators in dire straights

Event Date: 16/02/2016
TAYLOR, Keith (Greens/EFA, GB).
TRAN Public hearing ' Towards a European Road Safety Area '
Reference: EP-031806A
Copyright: � European Union 2016 - Source : EP.

A Sting Exclusive: the EU referendum is about fighting for an outward-looking Britain

Yesterday the EU Council of Foreign Ministers held an extraordinary meeting to discuss the recent developments in Ukraine. The Council urged Russia to immediately withdraw its armed forces to their areas of permanent stationing. In the absence of de-escalating steps by Russia, the Council agreed that it will decide about consequences such as suspension of bilateral talks on visa matters. From left to right: José Manuel Garcia-Margallo Marfil, Spanish Minister for Foreign Affairs and Cooperation, Laurent Fabius, French Minister for Foreign Affairs, Federica Mogherini, Italian Minister for Foreign Affairs. (The Council of the European Union Audiovisual Services 3/3/2014).

Europe enters uncharted waters with Kiev-Moscow standoff

Press conference by Jan Kinšt, Member of the European Court of Auditors (on the right) and Mikael Bain, Head of Unite by the ECA. They presented a report entitled, “Have the Members States and the Commission achieved value for money with the measures for diversifying the rural economy?”

The EU spent €158 billion on vague, open-ended rural projects

José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission participated in a debate about the future of Europe with 150 citizens in Brussels; the Pan-European Citizens' Dialogue. A lot of questions were asked about sharing financial responsibilities in the Eurozone. (EC Audiovisual Services, 27/03/2014).

Commission publishes the first report on the issuance of a Eurobond

ECOFIN Council. Michel Barnier, Member of the European Commission, Vitor Constancio, Vice-President of the European Central Bank, (from left to right). The central banker may look timid before the French showman but he clarified that the ECB needs clear-cut procedures. (Council of the European Union, 18/12/2013).

Eurozone close to agreeing on a Banking Union

Boris Johnson, Mayor of London, on the left, and Johannes Hahn, presenting the brochure entitled "The Crystal: a sustainable cities initiative by Siemens", EC Audiovisual Services,  28/02/2014

If on a summer’s night: is UK businesses’ “new deal” the only key to the “best of all worlds”?

DAVOS/SWITZERLAND, 20JAN16 - Joseph R. Biden Jr, Vice-President of the United States of America speaks during the special session at the Annual Meeting 2016 of the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, January 20, 2016.

  WORLD ECONOMIC FORUM/swiss-image.ch/Photo Remy Steinegger

WEF Davos 2016 LIVE: “European unity and cooperation is being called on question”, Vice President Joe Biden criticizes from Davos

May a parody constitute a copyright infringement? European Court of Justice to give the answer

Jean-Claude Juncker, President of the European Commission, and several members of the EC College participated in the European Parliament plenary session and the weekly Commission meeting, which was held on 05/07/2016. From the left to the right: Kristalina Georgieva, Commissioner for Budget and Human Resources, Jean-Claude Juncker and Maros Sefcovic, Vice-President of Commission, in charge of Energy Union. Date: 05/07/2016. Location: Strasbourg – European Parliamnet.© European Union, 2016 / Photo: Jean-François Badias.

EU free-trade agreements with Canada and US: imagine the fallout if put to national referendums

Martin Schulz, President of the European Parliament (on the right) and Alain Lamassoure , chairman of the budget committee of the legislative visited the Commission to negotiate with the Presidency the MFF 2014-2020 that is the next seven budgets of the European Union. (EC Audiovisual Services 27/06/2013).

New round of bargaining for the 2014 EU budget late in autumn

Journey of my life

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s