The ECB still protects the banks at the expense of the EU taxpayers

Emily O'Reilly European Ombudsman and European Commission President Manuel Barroso. (European Ombudsman, photographic library).

Emily O’Reilly European Ombudsman and European Commission President Manuel Barroso. (European Ombudsman, photographic library).

In a courageous decision, Emily O’Reilly, the European Ombudsman, condemned the decision of the European Central Bank not to disclose a letter the central bank’s then President, Jean-Claude Trichet, wrote to the Irish Finance Minister in November 2010. O’Reilly stated: “I regret that the Governing Council of the ECB has wasted an opportunity to apply the principle that, in a democracy, transparency should be the rule and secrecy the exception. At a time when so many people have been, and are, suffering as a result of austerity arising from the economic crisis, the very least a citizen can expect is openness and transparency from those who make decisions that directly impact on their lives and on the lives of their families. Following an inspection of the letter, I am unconvinced by the Governing Council’s explanation for continuing to keep it secret.” Let’s follow the facts.

In December 2011 an Irish journalist had asked for the disclosure of the letter. He had good reasons to suspect that it included pressure on the Irish government, to enter the EU’s bailout program the previous year. It’s clear by now that the ECB had forced then the Irish taxpayers to repay at face value the imprudent loans some major German and the French banks had accorded to the Irish lenders. All those banks kept investing in the Irish real estate bubble, despite knowing that it will burst.

The criminal part of the whole affair is that the Irish taxpayers were forced to undertake and repay the loans of the failed Irish banks at face value by the EU and ECB. The Irish banks had borrowed money from major German and the French lenders. In a similar occasion, though, Iceland refused to recognize the fraudulent loans of its own three banks which collapsed at the same time as their Irish counterparts in the aftermath of the 2008-2009 credit crisis.

Iceland resisted

European Sting writer Maria Milouv on 13 December 2013 noted “Kaupthing along with Landsbanki and Glitnir, the three major Icelandic banks, went bankrupt in 2008… Unlike the rest of the western countries, Iceland’s taxpayers didn’t cover the losses of those careless banks neither did they compensate their equally careless creditors. On the contrary Ireland, confronted with exactly the same problem – when the Irish banking system collapsed – was forced by the European Central Bank to borrow around €90 billion and instructed to bail out all fraudulent bankers”.

To be noted that Ireland spent another €70bn from the country’s reserves to repay the loans of its failed banks. Today still nobody knows for sure who got all that money. Clearly Ireland went bankrupt because the EU and the ECB forced the country’s government to undertake and repay the loans of the Irish private banks in full. Before this arrangement which was engineered mainly by the ECB, Ireland’s sovereign debt was around 25% and today it has reached 125% of GDP.

Ireland forced to repay

Coming back to O’Reilly’s Press release issued last Friday, it states “The ECB justified its refusal to disclose the letter in 2011 by the need to protect Ireland’s financial stability. According to the ECB, the letter was sent in the context of significant market pressure and extreme uncertainty as to the prospects for the Irish economy”. Obviously the ECB doesn’t reveal the whole truth now. The Irish exchequer didn’t run any danger neither did the Irish economy as a whole. Only the three major Irish banks were in danger of collapse as they finally did (Anglo-Irish Bank, Bank of Ireland Allied Irish Banks), threatening to take with them in the abyss their lenders in Germany and France. The country went bankrupt and was forced to borrow from Eurozone €90bn, only after it undersigned the debts of its banks.

The problem is that the ECB and the EU didn’t allow any negotiations between the Irish Republic and its taxpayers on the one side who were about to undertake and repay the debts of the country’s banks, and the Irish lenders’ lenders on the other. The ECB and the EU demanded that the German and the French lenders of the Irish banks should be reimbursed at full face value for their imprudent loans. In all previous banking crises of the last fifty years no banks were repaid at par value for their bad loans.

Who covers whom?

This is probably the reason why the ECB still rejects the disclosure of this letter. It might contain proofs that the people involved in the case, may have personal responsibilities, because their behavior enforced disproportionate financial responsibilities on the Irish side, in direct contrast with the practice followed in similar cases, like the Latin American debt crisis of 1980s.

It’s obvious then that the ECB still has to protect not Ireland’s financial stability, but its own people who were directly involved in this affair. A well- documented lawsuit in the European Court of Human Rights though, on the grounds of the violation of the rights of the Irish taxpayers and the disproportional compensation of the French and the German lenders, may produce very interesting results. Probably such a lawsuit may be based on the statement of the following statement of the Ombudsman “At a time when so many people have been, and are, suffering as a result of austerity arising from the economic crisis, the very least a citizen can expect is openness and transparency from those who make decisions…”












the European Sting Milestones

Featured Stings

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Better care, stronger laws needed to save 30 million babies on the brink of death

Human rights: breaches in Iran, Saudi Arabia and Sudan

China hopes EU Commissioner De Gucht drops super anti-dumping tariff on solar panels

Paradise islands of Pacific increasingly vulnerable to climate change, as UN boosts resilience

These countries are home to the highest proportion of refugees in the world

COP21 Breaking News_03 December: Argentina Accepts KP Amendment

Top UN official urges Russia and Ukraine to step away from further confrontation at sea

A ‘charismatic leader’ dedicated to making the world a better place for all: officials bid farewell to former UN chief Kofi Annan

Brazil: A strategic partner for the EU

UN committed ‘to support the Libyan people’ as Guterres departs ‘with deep concern and a heavy heart’

The Chinese retail revolution is heading west

Iran: UN rights chief ‘deeply disturbed’ by continuing executions of juvenile offenders

Foreign direct investments the success secrete of Eurozone

Reality Shock

Vaccinations and the movement of anti-vaccers

Europe’s poor investment in digital is threatening prosperity. Here’s what its start-ups need

On European immigration: Europe’s Missing Citizens

Does May have enough time in Parliament to table a soft Brexit deal?

Is there a way out of the next financial crisis? Can more printed money or austerity save us all?

US, Russia oblige each other in Syria and Ukraine selling off allies

The European Sting @ the European Business Summit 2014 – Where European Business and Politics shape the future

The Sichuan Province of China presents its cultural treasure to the EU

2014 will bring more European Union for the big guys and less for the weak

Direction Wakanda: finance methods to make Africa a superhero continent

A hot autumn after a cool summer for Europe

Light at the end of the Eurozone tunnel

How banking with blockchain can stamp out corruption and increase financial inclusion

4 key ways countries can finance their SDG ambitions

Cyprus President urges collective leadership to address ‘root causes’ of world’s crises

Italy and Greece zeroed their fiscal deficits, expect Germany’s response

Who really cares about the 26.2 million of EU jobless?

Strong multilateral institutions key to tackling world’s dramatic challenges, UN chief says In Moscow

From Grexit to Brexit: UK industry now says the in/out referendum is good for your health

May a parody constitute a copyright infringement? European Court of Justice to give the answer

The EU threatens to occupy Libya militarily; is another colonial war brewing?

COP21 Breaking News_09 December: List of Recent Climate Funding Announcements

Lessons from dealing with the collapse of Lehman Brothers

Here are 5 of the biggest threats to our oceans, and how we can solve them

Farmers on the frontline in battle against drug-resistant microbes: UN health agency

High-flyers: China is on top of the world for skyscraper construction

UNICEF delivers medical supplies to Gaza in wake of deadly protests

Japan should reform retirement policies to meet challenge of ageing workforce

How to test if Kiev’s ‘Maidan’ was an authentic revolt or a well-planned operation

World Food Day: here’s what the UN is doing to fix ‘intolerable’ wrong of hunger

UN, Somali Government seek $80 million in immediate relief for flood-affected populations

UN urges ‘maximum restraint’ as Israel-Hamas tensions rise over rocket attack

Tax crimes: MEPs want EU financial police force and financial intelligence unit

Commission Vice-President Rehn exaggerates Eurozone’s growth prospects

UNESCO experts ready to assist reconstruction of iconic Notre Dame, following devastating blaze

Why capital markets have no more reservetions about Eurozone

European Youth Capital 2018 : Cascais

Ahead of key UN-backed Marrakech migration conference, youth recount harrowing journeys

Argentina’s agro-food sector is growing remarkably, but agriculture policies are not keeping pace

Haitian President at General Assembly calls for essential development aid as UN mission shifts away from peacekeeping

Summer 2019 Economic Forecast: Growth clouded by external factors

Yemen talks: Truce agreed over key port city of Hudaydah

From philanthropy to profit: how clean energy is kickstarting sustainable development in East Africa

Draghi hands over to banks €77.7 billion more

Zeid calls for ICC probe into Myanmar Rohingya crisis

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s