EU Justice Scoreboard 2019: results show the continuing need to protect judicial independence

Jourova 2019_

Vĕra Jourová, Member of the EC in charge of Justice, Consumers and Gender Equality, will give a press conference on the EU Justice Scoreboard 2019.

This article is brought to you in association with the European Commission.


Today, the European Commission publishes the 2019 EU Justice Scoreboard, which gives a comparative overview of the independence, quality and efficiency of justice systems in EU Member States.

It provides national authorities with information to help them improve their justice systems. The results are mixed and show relative improvements with regard to the efficiency of justice systems and the quality of justice. At the same time, the Scoreboard shows there are growing challenges with regard to the perception of judicial independence.

Věra Jourová, European Commissioner for Justice, Consumers and Gender Equality said: “The 2019 EU Justice Scoreboard comes at a time when challenges to the rule of law are mounting in some places in Europe. I am pleased to see that many countries continue to improve their judiciary. Sadly, some others are reversing the positive trends. There are still too many EU citizens who don’t see their justice systems as independent and who are waiting too long for justice to be served. ”

The seventh edition of the EU Justice Scoreboard continues to develop the different indicators and deepens its focus on judicial independence as a key element to uphold the rule of law in Member States.

One of the new elements of the 2019 EU Justice Scoreboard is that it provides an overview of disciplinary regimes regarding judges in national justice systems and safeguards in place to prevent political control of judicial decisions. The Scoreboard also presents the management of powers over national prosecution services justice systems, including the appointment and dismissal of prosecutors, which are key indicators for the independence of a prosecution service.

 

The key findings of the 2019 edition include:

  • Some positive trends on the efficiency of justice systems: The Scoreboard shows that over eight years (2010-2017) positive developments can be observed in most of the Member States identified in the European Semester as facing specific challenges. Since 2010, in nearly all of those Member States, the length of first instance court proceedings has decreased or at least remained stable. Moreover, first instance proceedings in money laundering court cases take up to a year on average. However, in some Member States facing challenges in this area, proceedings can still take two or more years.
  • Challenges as regards perception of judicial independence are growing: According to a Eurobarometer survey published today, in two-thirds of Member States, the perception of judicial independence has improved, as compared to 2016. However, compared to last year, the public’s perception of independence has decreased in about three-fifths of all Member States[1]. Possible ^political interference or pressure is the main reason for the perceived lack of independence of courts and judges. For national prosecution services, the Scoreboard shows that there is a tendency in some Member States to concentrate management powers, such as evaluation, promotion, transfer of prosecutors, in the hands of a single authority.
  • Quality of justice: overall, in 2017, general government expenditure on law courts remained stable across the EU. To improve the quality of judgments (based on data from European judicial networks) most courts provide specific training to judges on the structure and style of reasoning and drafting of judgments. In some Member States, court users can ask for clarifications of court decisions. Compared to previous years, online access to court judgments has improved, especially as regards the publication of judgments of the highest instance: 19 Member States now publish all civil/commercial and administrative judgments.

 

Next steps

The findings of the 2019 Scoreboard were already taken into account for the country-specific assessment carried out within the 2019 European Semester. The findings will also feed into the preparation of the Commission proposals for the 2019 country-specific recommendations.

These policy recommendations are discussed amongst Member States in the Council. EU leaders endorse them in June before the Council adopts them in July. Governments then incorporate the recommendations into their reform plans and national budgets for the following year.

 

Background

Launched in 2013, the EU Justice Scoreboard is one of the tools in the EU’s rule of law toolbox used by the Commission to monitor justice reforms undertaken by Member States and feeds into the European Semester. The annual EU Justice Scoreboard assesses the independence, quality and efficiency of national justice systems. This comparative tool is complemented by country-specific assessments, presented in the Country Reports, which enable a deeper analysis based on the national legal and institutional context.

The Scoreboard focuses on the three main elements of an effective justice system:

  • Efficiency: indicators on the length of proceedings, clearance rate and number of pending cases.
  • Quality: indicators on accessibility, such as legal aid and court fees, training, monitoring of court activities, budget, human resources and standards on the quality of judgments.
  • Independence: indicators on the perceived judicial independence among the general public and companies, on safeguards relating to judges and on safeguards relating to the functioning of national prosecution services.

Improving the effectiveness of national justice systems is a well-established priority of the European semester — the EU’s annual cycle of economic policy coordination. The EU Justice Scoreboard helps Member States to achieve this by providing an annual comparative overview of the functioning of national justice systems. When serious challenges are identified in individual country reports, the Council, on a proposal from the Commission, adopts targeted country-specific recommendations.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Eurozone banks are unable to support real economy’s dawning growth

Young New Yorkers bring robots, and a glimpse of the future, to UN Headquarters

Doctors are humans too: the benefits of embracing your mental status

Climate change and health – can medical students be the solution?

Does Draghi have another ace up his sleeve given his Quantitative Easing failure?

‘We can’t stop COVID-19 without protecting health workers’: WHO chief

As Yemen relief operations face funding gap, timing of surge in violence ‘couldn’t be worse’

This is what a Green New Deal for Europe could look like

Election-related violence claims 85 lives in Afghanistan: UN report

Education: EU increases its commitment to Global Partnership for Education with a pledge of €700 million for 2021-2027

How virtual tourism can rebuild travel for a post-pandemic world

Colourism: How skin-tone bias affects racial equality at work

MEPs commend Ukraine‘s reform efforts and denounce Russian aggression

EU-UK relations: MEPs approve rules to ensure Eurotunnel safety and cooperation

How a more integrated approach could help to end energy poverty

In Libya, Guterres ‘deeply concerned’ by risk of fresh military confrontation, urges restraint

Aid stepped up to Syria camp; new arrivals say terrorists blocked their escape

European Youth Capital 2019 announced: Novi Sad, Serbia

European Citizens’ Initiative: Commission registers ‘End the Cage Age’ initiative

Eurozone: Economic Sentiment Indicator recovering losses

How fixing broken food systems can help us meet all the SDGs

Towards a seamless internal EU market for industrial goods

Hurdles of the COVID-19 Vaccination Campaign

State aid: Commission concludes that recapitalisation of German NordLB is market conform

Parliament calls on member states to fully exploit the European Youth Guarantee

Syrian crisis: EU mobilises an overall pledge of €6.9 billion for 2020 and beyond

Why support for Latin America’s early tech hubs is vital for the region

Global Goals offer ‘special opportunity’ to change course of development, Bosnian leader tells General Assembly

Commerce is on the cusp of radical change. Is your organization ready?

Microplastics have been found in Rocky Mountain rainwater

Why nature is the most important stakeholder of the coming decade

Arlington, USA: kick-off of the fifth round of the EU-US boxing match

5 challenges for government adoption of AI

Joint UN-Red Cross appeal to end rising sexual violence as a weapon of war

Obama, Crimea and the TTIP pill

What is a gender parity accelerator, and how does it work?

IMF – World Bank meetings: US – Germany clash instituted, anti-globalization prospects visualized

Questions and Answers on the EU Digital Covid Certificate

Beware the fragility of the global economy

EU and UK reach agreement in principle on fishing opportunities for the remainder of 2021

Has the EU economy truly revived from the financial crisis?

Why carbon capture could be the game-changer the world needs

Listen to the future – how 26 youth-led organizations are supercharging the UN’s Global Goals

The EU Spring Summit set to challenge austerity

Milk, fruits and vegetables distributed to schoolchildren thanks to EU programme

After COVID-19, we must rethink how we find and produce new drugs

How can we measure real progress on the Sustainable Development Goals?

Iraq: UN mission urges ‘maximum restraint’ following deadly attack on foreign troops

‘We will not give up on looking for peace for South Sudan’: UN deputy chief

Hunger in Yemen: WFP considers aid suspension in face of repeated interference by some Houthi leaders

Northern Bahamas ravaged by ‘disaster of epic proportions’ as UN releases $1 million in emergency funds

Mergers: Commission refers acquisition of newly created joint venture by Telefónica and Liberty Global to the UK competition authority

European Green Deal: Commission presents actions to boost organic production

10 surprising things that rely on artificial intelligence

UN chief lauds Fijians as ‘natural global leaders’ on climate, environment, hails ‘symbiotic relationship’ with land and sea

UN human rights chief denounces grave ‘assaults’ on fundamental rights of Palestinian people

Why the Fourth Industrial Revolution could spell more jobs – not fewer

Three things Nigeria must do to end extreme poverty

Concorde is a reminder that the only way for innovation is up

Coronavirus: Commission concludes talks to secure future coronavirus vaccine for Europeans

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s